I love the idea, and it’s nice to see someone working it out and asking for feedback. I’ve been looking for a good bag for a while, and while there are some out there, none have seemed to “jump out at me.” Maybe I’m looking in the wrong places, I dunno.
First thing is, I went to that webpage to look at pictures like you said, but it’s locked out by a password.
As for the designs, I really like the padded, silk-lined interior on the first one, but the overall construction of the second one looks MUCH better. I’m sure some of it has to do with hand-made vs machine-made. don’t get me wrong, a soft back would be super nice, but against the elements, stains, bumps, drops, etc., I think the second one (“basic” I think?) will send the test of time a lot better. It would be nice if the outside material was somehow “resistant” to liquids, just in case of it pouring outside, or random guy with a soda goes OOPS! all over you bag. Also, the “basic” seems to hold its form a lot better, so it looks more like an everyday messenger bag (that’s a good thing imo.)
Also, while I do really like the “slot” for the joystick, I immediately have to ask: is there any “additional support” for the actual joystick piece? Meaning, let’s say somehow the bag falls and it lands on its face. Is there anything besides the typical padding that’s going to absorb the hit? Is it extra thick there? Or is the padding in the outside front of the bag extra thick/supportive? I think that’s one of my biggest concerns with finding the right bag: having the right kind of support for the joystick itself, without it really “looking like it” too much. One idea I literally just thought of: Instead of just thickening the case itself, maybe you could make front of the case a little more supportive and then also the “flap” extra cushion-y to hide some of the bulk?
I dunno, I’m just spewing out thoughts quickly before I head to work, but again I think it’s awesome that you want to do this and make it right. As it stands, I’m very interested myself, especially so if I can pick the colors of the outside and inside.
Thanks!
~~Nate
P.S. - one more thought: any chance you could design the “front pouch” to also have the slot for a stick, but on the left instead of the right? Or there be a way to have it customized that way? What I’m getting at, is… Is there a way to design it so you have TWO sticks inside, facing each other? I don’t know what other people do, but it can be somewhat common for me to drag both sticks along with me when going somewhere, either for a friend to use, or as a failsafe at a tournament.
Thanks again!