So Necrotrophic goes down as a troll and shit poster.
I took you for a idiot, and still do.
Saying after the fact that you been trolling sounds more like a defense to me.
Don’t like or back out now that you realize you just victimized your self.
But the thread been entertaining to say the least.
I find it hard to believe that you guys are gullible enough to take everything on the internet seriously.
That’s not to say that everything I said was fucking around. Tone is everything, gotta pay attention to context. Mostly when I troll, I half think you guys can figure it out or are playing along
posts like “u” over something so inane as hot linking shouldn’t be assumed to be serious. Cmon now. You guys gotta step it up.
Political theory, and social theory, and anything that isnt real science or pure logic cannot be discussed without the use of real world examples amd all thr variables that come with the execution of those ideas. Idealized social theory, amd the subscription to " i must always use standardized defenitions" is retarded because you cant treat social science as a real science. No social theory has or ever will stand up to the level of scrutiny scientific theories regularly stand up to.
Ita why you cannot seperate the practical with theory, because its all connected. We know what happens when people try amd establish a communist society. It fails, and sure it emds up not being real communism, but thats the practical real world consequence of attempting such a retarded idea. It doeant matter if it wasnt real communism, dicussing the idea is a waste of time because we already know the consequence of that exexution. A more interesting argument is taking apart the idea through the eyes of experience, discuss why its such a crappy idea, and develop a new system that circumvents amd addresses the real suffering caused by said system. Discussing the idea of communism in any other manner is fucking retarded and some 1st grade shit tier level of critical thinking amd synthesis.
Also, if the theory fails during execution, then its a shit theory. Period.
Also, Imagine if scientists would tell people who cited examples that proved their theory wrong.
Oh, but that wasnt a real black hole because it dodnt meet these arbitrarily defined paramaters i made up.
This is why the social sciences are a fucking joke.
Communism is distinct from Marxism though, there are many Communists who are not Marxists.
When people criticize communism they’re really criticizing Marxism most of the time. If we’re going to be technical, really they’re criticizing Leninism
You shouldn’t assume that because I say we haven’t had real communism that I believe we should necessarily be going for it, especially in a Marxist context. The system that actually works depends on circumstances at the time. Bakunin is an example of someone who has brought forth ideas about communism without marxism. He’s not only associated with communism though, but socialism in general
Well this was supposed to be about Jank solar tech, but I said Fuck it as soon as the thread derailed into a communism “debate”.
And well that completely derailed as Necrotrophic turned out to be this idiot Troll.
This is the current state of the thread, and it probability get shut down soon.
its not my fault you learn about politics from dictionary.com. they give colloquial definitions not related to the concepts invented by the actual movement its self.