A few arewas of disagreement. I won’t argue tiers, because 1) They’revery subjective. 2) The ones you have listed are about right. I’m questioning sticking Vega is Second Tier, but it’s not far off. Also, I’ve always been opposed to the way the tiers are named, I would prefer to name them: “Top Tier”, “Almost Top Tier”, “Second Tier”, and “Middle Tier”. That kinda helps alleviate the impression that the lowest tier is “bottom tier”. Helps make it clearer that the final tier isn’t that much worse off than the top tier.
Only one main argument: Honda is not a bad character in V-Ism. He’s got a legitimate anti-air VC in V-Ism, at least. I would still stick him in the 3rd tier.
V-Dhalsim supposedly is just as good.
Also because V-Ism can be used as a reaction to other people’s V-Isms. It protects him when he Jumps in against characters with Anti-Air VC’s. Also, when he needs to win a round, it allows for an almost guaranteed SPD.
Not sure about X-Ism. I know her Hooligan throw (low catch or air-to-air catch) does 33% damage, but that doesn’t justify her being the best Ism. I think V-Ism might still be the best Ism for her, because of the inherent aid that V-Ism gives.
V-Ism 100% better than A-Ism. Without V-Ism, she can’t beat Zangief. And her anti-air Custom Combo does way too much damage to be trivial. Makes her way more deadly, and also gives her some free SPDs in clutch situations.
Don’t deny X-Ism Birdie, who I think is the best. Damage is huuuge and really easy to Combo into his Super (if you ever land a Counter Hit Crouch Fierce, Level 3 Super is for free if you Buffer on 2nd Hit). He can’t do much else besides brute force the enemy to death, so the aided VC’s and A-Ism Supers don’t really add to his game much. He’s gotta do the damage in whatever way he can. Basically, I think Birdie is probably legit in all three Isms.
Again, reiterating that V-Ism Honda is the best, by far, and actually makes him fairly competent.
But she’s the Sodom Killer!!! (No, she actually isnt’, she sucks. That is an inside joke between me and my friends. Please ignore. ^_^).
Lastly, and I know my opinion on this differs greatly from everyone else, where do people think the New Challengers (Dee Jay, Fei Long, T. Hawk, Guile, and Evil Ryu) fall into these tiers from the home versions?