yeah that’s part of the problem. YOU GOT TO MAKE MAKOTO #1!!!
j/k
There are many ways to get in… You do have to be patient. The thing is, you have to be satisfied with chipping them to death and punishing the little things. Yes you will take chip from sonic booms and FADC SRKs. Whatever. Take solice in knowing that once you finally do get in… and you will get in, you will take AT LEAST 10x the chip you received away from their life. Makoto does HELLA damage, and is confusing is hell once she gets in. Just be more patient. Don’t dash as much (even though her dash is 23452498 times better now…), and use other ways of getting in. I’m thinking more Tsurugis, more f.:mp:'s, less dashing, less Focus Dashing. More footsie war and less running into stuff. Compete with the footsies with s.:mk: and c.:mp:. Anti air properly. Punish mistakes accordingly. This is how you consistently win with Makoto. The other stuff comes later… retain your Street Fighter Fundamentals and the wins will come.
You are correct… it is dificult to do kara kara consistently. What you need is a setup, or a few setups to get yourself comfortable with it. The one I used for a long time is meaty s.:mp: Kara EX Karakusa. This one is almost impossible to defend against if the opponent gets hit or blocks the s.:mp:. If the s.:mp: doesn’t hit then the Karakusa never came out. it took a few days, but once I got used to the motion, I was able to apply it in many other situations after setting it up with moves that prevent jumping/backdashing. Most notably:
-c.:mp:, Hayte Cancel, HK Karakara (set up with c.:mp HC, IA HK Tsurugi first)
-FFS, HK Karakara (after landing at least 1 FFS combos)
-combo into HP Hayate, EX Karakara (after punishing at least 1 backdash/jump after Hayate)
-UTK, dash, f.:hk: (hold), HK Karakara (after landing Yamase post corpse hop and/or punishing a backdash after corpse hop)
-c.:lp:c.:lp: EX Karakara (after doing a few c.:lp: c.:lp: s.:mp: block strings)
this is all from practicing it from that one situation. So if you’re having trouble, These might help you out as well. There are many more setups, but these are the ones I use most often.