The SRK Movie Fanatic Thread (REVIEWS, QUESTIONS, RANTS, STARS...ETC.) EVERYTHING!

i thought i was the only person that liked Sunshine. everyone i know seems to hate it.

i enjoyed it. great visuals.

There is a general tendency for people to hate sci-fi movies in general, unless they’re obscenely stupid. Like Independence Day.

:rofl: true, but Sunshine is kinda different. Act III is usually what people split on. some groups hated all of it until Act III; other groups loved it until Act III. beret-wearing internet movie critics say stuff like ā€œit didn’t know what it was supposed to be,ā€ or ā€œit got ridiculous.ā€ i’m just saying i enjoyed it. i also enjoy Troma movies, disgusting pornography, and Nu-Metal, so probably don’t listen to me… :wonder:

it’s definitely a movie to watch on Blu-Ray (i own the DVD and even that looks amazing). and the commentary tracks are great.

watchmen review up (all my reviews are intended for those that have seen the film)

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/vine/journal_view.php?journalid=495988&view=public

Anyone who didn’t like the first 2 acts but liked the third don’t know anything about films let alone what it takes to make a good one. The third act wasn’t bad or implausible by it’s own standards, or any of that it simply was too conventional and not up to par with everything that preceded it.

I’ll have my review up later tonight, for now I will say boyle is THE FUCKING MAN. He’s like dhalsim so versatile he can do anything well he made a damn good ā€œzombieā€ film and I use that term loosely, a damn good family film, a stylish thriller with heavy violence, train fucking spotting, a great romance film, and a really good but uneven sci fi film…wow what a way to not only run the gamut of genres but do well in each:tup:

Just saw a dvdrip of Martyrs

[media=youtube]walAzan9Cj8[/media]

Such a fucked up movie omg

Trailer screams ā€œFrench Hostelā€ to me. Is it any better than the other 5000 ā€œperson tied to chair/tortured for 45 minutesā€ movies released lately?

I saw High Tension and really enjoyed it and a couple other recent French horror movies have been on my radar but that trailer makes the movie look really generic and dull.

martyers shits on any horror movie you have seen period…

im outi

Roberth

Sunshine review is up

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/vine/journal_view.php?journalid=495988&view=public

I thought Sunshine was pretty lame…just my two cents though

W. was fucking hilarious to me. It’s probably my favorite Oliver Stone film, surpassing even NBK.

Valkyrie was pretty good. One of Tom Cruise’s better movies for sure.

Slumdog had some GREAT cinematography going on. Very cool little movie.

As for Watchmen, in general, I like it. But it was NOT what it could have been. Some scenes just felt ā€œsold outā€ to me, or Hollywooded out, if you will. The story could’ve benefited from a more intelligent director. The ending was kind of butchered (the fucking squid is supposed to be present, fuck your ā€œlogicā€ Mr. Snyder), the pacing was somewhat inconsistent (particularly around the mid-point of the film), certain characters weren’t developed properly, and the music choices were annoying as hell at times (ā€œHallelujahā€ during the sex scene comes to mind. Hell that whole scene is annoying). Dr. Manhattan was unquestionably the most faithful thing about the film, looking at the graphic novel. Well, Rorschach too. Rorschach and Manhattan are what I like most about the movie. Despite its faults, I’d probably give it a 7.5, maybe an 8.

That’s it for recent movies I’ve seen that had any lasting effect for me.

You would be beyond wrong in that assessment. I have not seen the film, but based solely off the reaction of the true horror fans I know, I’m guessing this film will basically rip you out of your seat and fuck your head for days after seeing it. I will pass on watching it myself as that level of visceral experience isn’t for me.

I saw this topic posted over at the ReelViews forum, so I’m posting it both here and on Freak Safari. I personally found it interesting enough to devote an afternoon to making my list and slashing it down.

Public muthafuckin Enemies

here is my top ten of the 2000’s off the top of my head:

American Psycho
Battle Royale
Collateral
The Descent
Ghost World
Grindhouse
Irreversible
Return of the King
Martyrs
Requiem for a Dream

Runners Up:

Mean Creek
Grizzly Man
Mysterious Skin
Kill Bill (combined)

Oh shit this will be fun I love lists.

watchmen review is up

http://www.rottentomatoes.com/vine/journal_view.php?journalid=495988&view=public

now with pics =)

OZ’s top 10 films 00-09: the top5 are in my top10 films of all time:rock:

zoolander
dark knight
batman begins
wall-E
zodiac
there will be blood
children of men
memento
no country for old men
eternal sunshine

Honorable mentions:
LOTR trilogy
kill bill
before sunset
twighlight samurai
2046
minority report
sin city
sideways
iron man
oldboy

2000s Top Ten So Far:

13 Tzameti
Ichi the Killer
Doppelganger
Gozu
Sin City
Oldboy
There Will Be Blood
28 Weeks Later
Requiem for a Dream
Versus

Movies this decade I really liked and would rewatch years after the hype died down. Not ranked

The Prestige
Frailty
Internal Affairs
City of God
Pitch Black
American Psycho
Snatch
Kill Bill vol 1+2
Batman movies
Unbreakable

There are so many movies this decade (examples off the top of my head: Gran Torino, Syriana and Body of Lies, all of Spielberg’s directed sci-fi movies, Children of Men, V for Vendetta) that had a brilliant subject matter and bright moments, but I thought didn’t really come together as a satisfying or entertaining movie.

After much agonizing, here is my top 10 of the 2000s. But first, my criteria, generally in the order that I employed them.

Criteria:

  • Did it come out in the 2000s?
  • Did I see it?
  • Do I like it?
  • Is it a good representative of the decade?
  • Do I believe it’ll stand the test of time?
  • Has its effect on me endured to this day?
  • Is it good enough to knock runners-up off the list?
  • Is it better than similar films of its time?

And now, the list. I alphabetized them, because the process of selecting them at all is a muddy one. Trying to further order them by quality would end up being arbitrary and pointless.

Adaptation. (2002)
Children of Men (2007)
The Dark Knight (2008)
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004)
Memento (2000)
Superman II: the Richard Donner Cut (2006)
The Visitor (2008)
There Will Be Blood (2008)
WALL-E (2008)
World Trade Center (2006)

some of my favorite movies of the 2000s that I can run off the top of my head.

  • 300 (I love this movie for the great cheesy fun it is. One of my best theater experiences of the decade was this in IMAX opening night)
  • American Psycho (basically made Bale)
  • Before Sunset (probably the best romance movie sequel ever)
  • City of God
  • The Dark Knight (best superhero movie since RoboCop)
  • Grizzly Man (Herzog never lost it)
  • Kill Bill (one of the best hack n slash samurai movies since Lone Wolf and Cub)
  • Man on Wire
  • Pineapple Express (I just totally dug like every moment of this movie)
  • there are others too like Charlie Kaufman stuff, Lost in Translation, the work of Alexander Payne, A History of Violence, Wes Andersen shit, etc.

but yeah it’s hard to evaluate a decade of cinema. sometimes you might see a movie long after the decade ended and it will easily be the best film of the era. Like how Martin Scorsese proclaimed The Horse Thief as the best movie of the 80s after seeing it in the nineties.

Not knocking your choice taito but damn never thought I’d see anyone in this thread put unbreakable as one of the very best films of the decade. And someone likes 28 weeks better then 28 days? daaaaaaaaamn.

GM superman2? ummm I thought only theatrical releases counted, anyways what’s with posting those bullet points as if anyone in this thread didn’t take all that into consideration lol but people around here love posting common sense.

maybe he didnt see 28dl…? thats easily the best zombie movie ever(IMO).\

I will make a top 10 list too I guess…no order.

  • training day
  • american psycho
  • dark knight
  • ironman
  • pinapple express
  • the manchurian candidate
  • blackhawk down
  • 28 days later
  • the island
  • eastern promises