@The_Shakunetsu
Overall i agree with everything, only thing i disagree with is the premise that any new treat must be locked as minor treat compared to Illuminati/Shadaloo
First because it kinda flat them all on the same box… take Mad Gear, S.I.N and Syndacate you mentioned
SIN for what we know could have been Shadaloo 2.0 if Seth was’nt weak, wich make it a way more advanced treat than “normal” crime org as the Syndacate.
The Syndacate itself “controlled Europe” wich make Mad Gear Gang look like kids games in comparision.
MGG look more something like the american gang C.Jack was part of
A thing typical of Capcom World is that (contrary to reality) orgs power is defined basically from theyr leader potential.
Shadaloo is identified by Bison’s power, even without destroy the HQ as in ASF, what will have been left?
Vega? Fang? Balrog? Anything will have been a waaaaay weaker version of Shadaloo
Illuminati are ancient and with links all over the world, but SF wise they became a relevant/known treat only in the last generation with Gill and Urien, because they’re powerful
Seth single handed made SIN being a treat because he was (relatively) powerful
Urien planned to create his own thing from zero (literally creating his army)
Gen was likely able to destroy Seth effortlessly like Bison did (and theorically be a potential treat to Bison itself), imagine if Gen was the boss of his own chinese mafia org… he will have been a better potential story arc villain than Seth lol
Or Necalli, imagine if he had his own cult of fanatics that summoned/resurrected him* and was actually well developed story wise to become the Bison-level treat of the prophecy… SFV events made a “coincidence” (Ryu and Sim being together) to avoid it
Capcom way of make orgs so linked to personal potential make things dynamic if they create new treats… is obvious (and hinted) many evil org exist in Capcom’s earth, all you need is make one of them become suddently more powerful because a new powerful leader took control of it
It can be a crazy dictator of a state, a mad scientist, a new terrorist leader, an ambitious criminal, a secret cult priest etc etc
Everything in SF is related to the individual ability, as good he is
Illuminati can be aware of all of them, but like they did for Shadaloo they let it be until they considered Bison a potential REAL treat (ASF)… as far we know they never did anything against them before SFV
Shadaloo itself had high and lows (directly connected with Bison’s high and lows) and never truly had the time to estabilish hegemony.
Like Raoh in HNK Bison likely know there are others that at some point will contend him the the world throne, but he doesn’t seem hurry to face them… see how we don’t see him do anything in particular to search/kill Akuma.
Bison (and so Shadaloo) is about SELF-strengthening, his plan is basically power-up himself to the point nobody will be able to stop him*, not find and destroy the competition
As you can see for Seth or Necalli in theory they can create out of nothing a new treat, but feel cheap to me… but i will still accpet them if they offer a new credible arc
But honestly i will prefer the Souther-Raoh approach, imagine a capcomesque Rugal that in the past fought to a draw Bison (think Akuma/Gen duel) and each agreed to go back on theyr path and postpone theyr final fight… somebody like that will be a cool af new Boss/treat, without need to shit on a past char SF3 style
- i think Bison himself summoned on purpose Necalli, or did it accidentally and was amused by it
**and in SFV he’s the Boss without get close to that level, getting stopped at 1 moon