It’s easy for you to retort with that rather than understand what I’m saying, but I don’t believe you’ve spent any meaningful time with a real game so meh.
I think HAV likes Super SF4 because he views Street Fighter as a concept. Positioning, spacing, reactions, footsies… as long as it’s there, it must be Street Fighter. I think that’s dumb, El Fuerte and Abel and Viper and Rufus and Option Selects dominating the game (note, dominating, not that they exist period) aren’t Street Fighter to me.
I view Street Fighter specifically. A type of style dominates the game (zoning, fireballs/uppercuts) and players play around that. It’s why I respect Shotos, while most new players think they’re ez mode. So while I can tolerate Alpha 2, adore any version of Street Fighter 2, or have some fun with CVS2’s insanity… I loathe SF4.
Because I don’t view SF4’s game being spiritually or conceptually similar, I think it spits in the face of what real SF is. I think Alpha 3 sucks too, so, hey. In SF4, all I see is that you get rewarded for getting punched in the face, what is traditional Street Fighter is raped in favor of “Sick canned mixxx ups”, and the things that make Street Fighter interesting are lost in favor of creating situations where you’re playing Street Fighter 3 without parries. And if you don’t believe me, look at AE and the people who ARE good at 4. Arturo said as much if you want that “cred.”
I don’t view Street Fighter as a concept, I view it very specifically. Real Street Fighter has real uppercuts, real damage, better pacing, and it still manages to be about match ups and a game where things are dominant because they’re good, not because they’re distilled. You don’t get rewarded for getting beat up, and the game doesn’t feel like a canned thought process for characters that used to have 4-5 frame medium normals without 10-11 frames of whiff recovery so that I can work in systems that reward people who suck (Focus Attack, Ultra).
What’s added doesn’t replace what is taken away to me. I don’t enjoy Street Fighter as a concept, so I say again:
Ono sucks. Try spending some time with a real game, you speak in generalities and if I get specific I just waste my time. Play what you want and stop asking about why old folks like old things lol.