Daaaamn. Who looks cleaner than everyone else (sans Forge)?
<-- This guy.
So Exodus has to be Hale. With only two mafia, the whole throwing one of their own under the bus thing seems too risky to go along with. They tried to save Combo_Knight by starting a lynch wagon on OZ in the hopes that WAH, Sumazndude, or myself would switch our vote to him. Clearly it didn’t work.
If somehow Exodus is clean, I’m putting my money on WAH.
Also, let us all take a small moment to laugh at the other guys for lynching their own pyro and having six extra pages of rubbish that hasn’t helped them find a mafia.
Combo_Knight FUCK YOU MAFIA SCUM I EXPOSED YOU LAST PAGE LIKE AN UNDERDEVELOPED PHTO! I TOLD YOU ID KILL YOU TODAY AND I DID HAHAHAHAHA! :chainsaw:
@exodus whether you’re mafia or not FUCK YOU! I’m almost tempted to remove you from my steam friends list because if you’re a civ you blatantly ignored my well thought out analysis of this thread last page and this page where I presented convincing evidence on why CK is mafia. And if you are mafia, you’re a poor one because you voted for me without having any evidence or reasoning to contradict my posts accusing CK. In most games the mafia at least try to bullshit their way into a semi plausible argument but no, not you, you were just like “well OZ is mafia cuz I said so I’m going to vote him for no reason”. I’m not mad that you voted for me, I’m mad because I spent several hours reading this thread multiple times and analyzing it and wracking my brain trying to figure out who’s mafia and you still voted for me with no LOGIC. If you made some kind of argument against my posts or pointed out contradictions in my accusations against CK than I wouldn’t be mad at you voting me. I feel like a dad with an ungrateful son who doesn’t realize all the hard work I do for him.
@forgedigger You’ve just embarrassed yourself and proven you are total ass at this game 
but you get a pass from me because this is your first mafia game so I’m not as mad at you as I am at exodus.
I’m most likely going to be killed tonight, so MEDIC protect me tonight, I know it’s kind of a tough choice for you because you have to choose between the useless confirmed civ or the guy who is responsible for killing a mafia but is not a confirmed civ. I understand that one of us will die tonight and you can only pick one, but seriously if you’ve been reading this thread you will see that I the first one to lead the charge against CK way before there was any “bandwagon” and who has out in more time and effort into this thread than anyone else deserves to be protected for at least one night. I earned that shit.
@forgedigger in case medic protects me and not you tonight please type out your last gasp NOW so it won’t matter if you get Aussie punched, I’ll do the same.
@orochizoolander you’re soo aggressive and loud O.o i have a tight schedule to keep to and i’m being extremely hesitant here… this is only my second game. if you saw my previous score you’d be laughing and drowning in your own tears of joy about how bad of a player i am… My suspicions should’ve implied that i simply agree with ForgeDigger’s suspicions towards you
@orochizoolander your aggressive replies towards questions accusing you can also imply that you’re trying to hide something… when you’re trying to hide something (i.e. role) you are most reactive towards questions that question your activity
btw, i’m not saying “you’re mafia” i’m simply looking at you
Preemptive last gasp:
I just wanted to get this out of the way before anyone gets any dumb ideas. I am not a Hale who threw my own spy under the bus just to avoid detection. Think about it, if I was Hale why would I be the first one to expose my own spy? Also I’ve had a lynch target on my back for awhile now so if I was Hale it would be stupid of me to call even more attention to myself and continue to stick my neck out.
WAH has been a little suspicious but he defended me early on with my poor wording of the roles instead of capitalizing and getting me lynched, also he supported me with my CK lynch vote early on so I’m convinced he’s a civ, Cyntalan was wrong about him just like he was wrong about hecatom. If WAH did turn out to be mafia he fucking deserves to win for tricking us. @forgedigger you should trust WAH.
Can we really learn anything from votes now that we have a mafia down?
you guys should be asking…who would pick CK as their spy?
I suck as a civ. >.<
So anyway. I have a theory. I’m going to wait out the night first. Posting my last gasp would mess with it. Nighty night. c;
the fact that a spy died and you voted on the spy as early as you could takes you off my sight…
zoo do they want to go after you tonight though, even when you are still on the fence for a lynch?
Are they going to get ForgeDigger out finally?
I counted up who wants you out.
It might be important to know who started that or at least the order of people pointing at you.
That’s like everyone that is left. Consider Combo knight knows he was guilty and knows if orochizoolander is Mafia too or a civilian like almost everyone else.
Combo was the behind the scenes Mafia. Would the other teammate, Hale, be the outspoken one, being the opposite kind of Mafia player? Or is he just a shadowy guy too?
But Hale has an Aussie Punch stock now so you won’t get to post a last gasp if you die…
MEDIC, I will understand if you choose to protect forgedigger instead of me as he is a confirmed civ and I’m not but seriously I fuckin found a mafia so I’ve done the heavy lifting for you guys so far I hope you protect me tonight I’m not done although finding the next mafia will be trickier as I’m less sure. Hopefully whoever you pick to protect is the one targeted by night kill.
Except you put the monkey wrench into play that we might lose if we just vote Combo Knight. Luckily Combo just laid down and took it.
but now you could die tonight. It might be you or me, after the last vote. zoolander looks more clean like you said because Combo tried to remove doubt from himself and place it all on zoolander. So zoolander might be hit too. I hope you guys learn from which one of us dies and who stays alive.
Your plan of action, “I would have gone hard at Alpha, or zoolander” sure sounds great, but we don’t have time to wait man. I took the initiative on ComboKnight. From everyone’s silence and not responding to him, it felt like you guys believed his words and that he was providing the right answers. Forge sure did, taking his response at face value back there–insightful button. So I’d imagine they’re leaving Forge alive thinking he is a non-factor. That’s their judgment of you, so don’t let them wave you off like you don’t matter, man.
You might have thought I’m talking too much like a Mafia before. But we have no time. Mafia already knows who I am, and who all of you are.
So will Mafia try to Kill zoolander tonight?
(he is the only one worried about the medic.)
Finally get ForgeDigger out and make a lot of suspicion because we no longer have a confirmed civ?
Get me out so there’s way less posts in here even if I’m not being the best leader? I might be unlynchable so they need to kill me. But they can also kill my suspects and really implicate me over the bandwagons. And leave me alive to point the finger at the wrong people even more.
Killing Augustus will definitely be used against us.
Same for Exodus but not nearly as much. Nobody is looking strongly at him, he is only considering OZ and Augustus.
You’re the first person on page 1 to say we should be looking at who the Hale isand what type of player he and/or the spy would be (newbie vs vet) then I later showed the flaw in why we shouldn’t assume Hale is someone with past game experience. I’ve already said you’re the only person I can trust besides forge obviously so I’m curious who is your Hale pick now given what we know so far? I’ll assume you’ve read my 2 long posts so I won’t repeat myself.
I’m still looking sideways at Augustus but exodus changing his vote to me makes me very unsure of him now, especially since he’s been in previous mafia games and would know CK is a decent mafia pick. Also as forge pointed out he is the only person who was on both the mrmattroxx and hecatom bandwagons and while AC warned him to not judge based on the raw data, at this point 3 times is more than just a coincidence.
I admit I might still get lynched, but as I said before I exposed Combo_Knight if I was wrong about him I would be willing to accept the possibility of being lynched. I knew I was right, but it felt so GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD to read @Pimpwilly post today confirming my suspicions.
Combo calling you out was probably the safe move. Everyone is looking at you for the lynch. I shut that down but people continued to suspect you, after what Combo said. Look really hard at those guys. They might have already known if Combo was making a play to save his own ass and know what team you are on.
Also from all the words on the medic I hope you know more than the Mafia team does about that. There are a lot of choices like protecting themselves. Lets see if that at least gets them to sweat until the deadline and maybe change targets a few times thinking they are going to be blocked. Yomi needs to be on point to scout out their moves and have the right counter and good decision.
I think a very important exchange going forward were these 2 things:
This one looks out of place and I wonder why you didn’t notice it:
BOTH italicized.
For someone who really wanted Combo out, he doesn’t want himself named sure, but why doesn’t he want you named? Why didn’t he ask about the reasons Forge had?
what’s wrong with thinking zoo is a Mafia?
“Slip up,” right there?
Its not too credible but maybe someone considered this too. I have no idea what you guys are thinking. You don’t speak up. While that places some doubt on you, Augustus wording and formatting choice does look suspect. He will have to explain it away even if it was nothing. Forge is cleared, he has the right and chance to go after everybody. Crazy he never went at Combo at all, the confirmed Mafia, but he has to pick it up now if he wants to win too.
I thought Exodus would be a Hale random choice from the start of the game. That still looks likely today. Augustus the same. Even though he’s like the wild card we don’t know about.
But someone had to know before the game whether Combo was a good player. So that puts it more on Exodus than Augustus unless he was following SRK Mafia games and watched the PHX Wright one.
Somebody lied and Forge is a Mafia. Or he’s getting D+ in the final grading for voting for every Civ and never a Mafia.
(Which is fine, like Urien gets D++ after a win because all the hits of his Tackles or Aegis super are always blocked.)
I was the first to put in the Combo Knight vote, against the grain and bandwagon. That’s not to say that’s a reason against Zoolander for going with the rest, because it was likely combo wasn’t being lynched that day so he maybe didn’t waste a vote or get the tie=no lynch if we got another voter.
But more like everyone is taking credit for the Combo Knight kill here, when I was the one who wanted him questioned and was the only guy questioning him :razzy: . At least that puts more targets out there for Mafia to kill. Alright we got Combo, get the other guys too, put your suspects out there. Show you can do it more than once after 4 of your guys die.
An explanation for my scarceness last phase: I had a football game last night and forgot that the deadline was 11AM (which is during school, mind you). I got 5 hours of sleep and didn’t have the time to read through all the posts before school. I didn’t want to risk DQs, so I went with my gut choice. I’m catching up on 35 posts I had to skip to vote now.