Fuzz, sometimes you gotta go balls out and make the hard choices. It’s not always clear but sometimes people find out who they are when their backs are to the wall.
Oh yeah, by the way, welcome @Vynce to replace CK. Something good happening woooo
Scenario: 4-6 Mafia, 14-12 Civs. We haven’t killed any Mafia, three of our power roles are dead. UC/Medic, Expedition Ace, & Human Lover which auto-recruited the Dormant Lover to the Mafia. A large number of civilians aren’t voting, aren’t reading, or are eternally low tier. The remaining Dormants, if they haven’t been recruited, are extremely unlikely to side with civilians due to large Mafia advantage. We have no Vigilante, no Detective, no Medic. If we’re making a comeback it’s not with the help of roles or fancy shit. And so far, even with two investigation results from Forge’s death Night 2, we’ve been doing an extremely poor job of even deciding on lynch candidates or how to press them, let alone actually finding the Mafia.
That wasn’t balls out, that was me having a hunch and nothing else and thinking it was enough to lynch one of the few players who was actually contributing a decent amount and was capable of playing well enough to drag the rest of us out of this shit. All it was was tunnel vision with a little asterisk next to it saying “singular subjective piece of evidence attached” and you know it. You’re just trying to keep this from being South Park 2.0 and I appreciate that, but I just need to be mad for a bit. I’ll shape up by day phase.
Headed to bed now, I’ll check in tomorrow. I’ll probably be less mopey after some sleep but goddammit.
Idk, maybe I could on Forge but not on Gamer.
You forgot yourself.
Well I know I’m clean, but I suppose so. I never felt knowing roles was my strong suit anyway honestly
So, something that was bothering me…
3 DQs this phase, 2 were civs, the 3rd was unknown. If 1 of the dqs was roled, they would be most likely to be replaced.
C_K I felt like he coulda been a dormant, or mafia… possibly even the lover. Need to go back and look at his interaction with OZ.
Anyway, Vynce_K is somebody we need to keep an eye on
I’ve so far just been playing this game on gut. I think I need to give it the proper attention it deserves
B)
I’m a regular civilian. (Congrats to me!)
Got some reading to do…
Foolish fools foolishly throwing around foolish accusations…
Guess I was right. Syn was not mafia.
I think at this point we need to try and grill the players who haven’t been saying much. I have a feeling that the mafia players are hidden among the less active.
Pimp Willy I don’t think is mafia at this point. Bious I’m having less suspicion about, but he’s still on my list. Cyntalan, Blindknagg and Augustus should be looked into more imo. And of course the current wallflowers if you can get them in here.
You want to lynch Augustus. Motherfucking Augustus. How is it so hard to comprehend that two people have made this mistake? Was I not being clear enough when I was talking to Blindknagg? If that’s the reason let me remedy that immediately.
Augustus = Eren = Civilian = Don’t Friggin Lynch Him
Because I just woke up and don’t remember everything. Remove Augustus from my list then.
…
Also, for the record, I didn’t directly want Augustus lynched, just looked into. My list isn’t for lynching, just for who we should perhaps focus on. Twice now these bandwagons on one player just have not worked.
Anyways, out of the player list, imo:
Blindknagg: Civ?
Augustus: Civ
Pimp Willy: Civ
DarkGeneral: ???
Skizzz: Civ
D’Nyc3: ???
jasonC: Civ
AlphaCommando: Civ
DukeC: Civ
Cyntalan: ???
RECESSIONTIME: ???
Sumazndude: ???
The Co-Jones: Civ (was this confirmed or was it only that he’s not mafia?)
Icege: ???
Bious: ???
The Chief: Civ
The ones marked ??? are the ones I think that should be focused on this go 'round. Blindknagg’s marking is since I’m not really sure one way or the other. D’Nyc3 might just not be around? I haven’t seen much of him and he did miss his vote this time, though he voted for Day 2. Similar case for @Skizzz.
I’m not gonna be around most of the day though so this’ll be my last contribution for a while. I might pop in in about 3 hours (around lunch-time here) but outside of that, I’ll be missing in action.
I’ll leave the rest to all of you.
Need clarification that Phase Info Dumps have provided players with insight. If not, will discontinue.
Oh my fuck, 21 pages?
Just saw that the other 2 DQs were civs too. Thanks for warming things up for me, compadres :tup:.
Synonym last gasp
Actually, this should be addressed.
@hecatom did you RNG to determine which of the 3 players would be replaced? You’re satisfying the curiosity of others. I know it didn’t matter who you chose.
Yes
I may go through the thread backwards.
@LordWilliam1234 Have you come under suspicion yet?
Oh, also- could someone list hard-confirmed civs?