Ok my noob provocateur belligerent post of the day:
My current Grixian spy reads:
@"Missing Person"
@Augustus
@Bious
@BullDancer
@Cyntalan
And before Bious comes in demanding justification, here it is:
MP - If you are civ, I feel your push on kaz is kinda weak and the reason you are pushing so hard is that you want to know that you are right about your read. However, more things point to you being Grixian. You cleared AKI as civ - you said he was playing like the usual wallflower (this was from one game of mafia where he was wallflower and one game of Arena where he was not and I KNOW he was PMing you in that game). You cleared AKI so fast on that experience in the same light that you accuse kaz after multiple games. When you explained your read:
Your first line is unnecessary defense - shows you are scared/hesitant to post but you go on. Point 2 - you say you have never told what the read is before. So how the hell does Bious know what it was? Unless Bious is in cahoots with you …more on him later. And final nitpick - you didn’t know you could change your vote? I know this isn’t your first rodeo but it is mine and even I knew that
But this coupled with not knowing about LPs, ignoring other evidence presented by other people in the game to push your own agenda - it’s just not what I expect from an experienced player playing as civilian.
Augustus - AKI implicated him in one of his two posts, probably to start a mafia accusing mafia ploy. MP - you pick up on this right away and have comments - further mafia accusing mafia yomi. Augustus starts to post more now that AKI and PW are dead and mentions something about PW’s edited post on the hunch that nobody saw it so he can say whatever the hell he wants to name names and garner suspicion away from the remaining mafia. MP, sure you implicate him this phase, but it’s only because your kaz read is not gaining traction and Augustus is basically a sacrifice to make MP look clean so he can survive til end game supplying further reads probably 2 or 3 civ “errors” and then maybe another mafia sac later on to regain cred. IMO, it’s the only way mafia can win now.
Bious - He’s not helping at all. Dodging my direct questions except for when I ask to forget everything in the past and ask the same question again and gives a wishy-washy answer. Half of his posts were dodging my questions or asking player x about how they feel about player y, and not really pushing the envelope with suspects imo. He asks everyone to post If-I-Dies/pre-last gasps whatever you want to call them and doesn’t do so himself. Shifty mafia play. Along with knowing MP’s tell on kaz without MP ever telling what the tell was? Suspect.
BullDancer - this should have been our day 1 lynch. His only defense of my new research of him using black decks in MtG was that he likes to win passively. Well in Mafia, the mafia can win passively by allowing the civs to kill each other. Civs can’t win passively (no lynch each day); they’ll get killed off. And he had nothing to say about him being active during the color selection process when he claimed he was on vacation so he didn’t pick colors.
Cyntalan - this one’s a stretch. And if you’ve been keeping up with what I did day 1, this is more of a poke/prod. But he goes out of his way to post a pic to prove he has a fever, when the first excuse was fine enough. Additional proof was unnecessary because no one was asking twice, but now I am. Cyntalan, what temp is your kid running? What medicine did your doctor prescribe? Wallflower making excuses - why? For all we know that thermometer was by the light bulb just before you took that pic.