Pie and co-jones are on my suspicious list for tomorrow, along with Blindknagg depending on how he votes tonight…but we’ll cross that bridge when we get there
Cross it now, in case you die. Why am I a suspect in your eyes?
Lol, I didn’t realize that I was browsing this thread past midnight last night, thought I only had until this morning to vote…Doesn’t change my stance on anything though. Will browse this thread once I get home in 2-3 hours.

3rdSTRikeLOVE:
WTF-AKUMA-HAX:
Well this phase is going to suck if nobody even considers the high vote getter’s opinion, then he turns up clean all over again.
Aidebit wanted to vote Soviet. Nobody voted Sovi3t. Nobody today wants to vote Soviet.
3SL wants to vote TCJones. Nobody wants to vote Co-Jones?
AC is a lot different as people do want to vote 3SL, where he wants us to vote.
Pie and co-jones are on my suspicious list for tomorrow, along with Blindknagg depending on how he votes tonight…but we’ll cross that bridge when we get there
Cross it now, in case you die. Why am I a suspect in your eyes?
If I die, i’ll get a last gasp anyway. I guess it would be an easy overlook by a mafia member who didn’t have the luxury of that sort of thing.
Seriously tho, I mentioned my suspicion of you yesterday because of that bs “cold-numbers” plan or whatever. I didn’t waste time reading it. Then you jumped on Aidebit when you saw what was happening…hmph sort of reminiscent of what you’re doing right now to me. Honestly why would you cast you’re vote for me, not even listening to what i had to say for myself in defense of AC’s sketchy “case” against me.

pietastic:
3rdSTRikeLOVE:
WTF-AKUMA-HAX:
Well this phase is going to suck if nobody even considers the high vote getter’s opinion, then he turns up clean all over again.
Aidebit wanted to vote Soviet. Nobody voted Sovi3t. Nobody today wants to vote Soviet.
3SL wants to vote TCJones. Nobody wants to vote Co-Jones?
AC is a lot different as people do want to vote 3SL, where he wants us to vote.
Pie and co-jones are on my suspicious list for tomorrow, along with Blindknagg depending on how he votes tonight…but we’ll cross that bridge when we get there
Cross it now, in case you die. Why am I a suspect in your eyes?
If I die, i’ll get a last gasp anyway. I guess it would be an easy overlook by a mafia member who didn’t have the luxury of that sort of thing.
Seriously tho, I mentioned my suspicion of you yesterday because of that bs “cold-numbers” plan or whatever. I didn’t waste time reading it. Then you jumped on Aidebit when you saw what was happening…hmph sort of reminiscent of what you’re doing right now to me. Honestly why would you cast you’re vote for me, not even listening to what i had to say for myself in defense of AC’s sketchy “case” against me.
Yep, you didn’t waste time reading it, and you didn’t waste time following up to see I’d set a trap.
You’re definitely my choice to die today.

on another note @Blindknagg did you plan on formulating ANY thoughts of your own or are you just going to keep inb4ing and doing what everybody, all the other mafia i mean, does?
I was more suspicious of AC at first but his post made me concider you another valid vote. I’ve seen how valuable he can be for us if he’s civ like in the last game so I’m not entirely sure on where my vote is going.
At the time of my post out of the two of you AC was the one that had started to make some discussion going and laid out why you should be lynched over him while you had been mostly wallflowering or making fluff posts (unless I missed something?) so that’s another reason why I think leaving AC alive for tomorrow may get us somewhere.

3rdSTRikeLOVE:
pietastic:
3rdSTRikeLOVE:
WTF-AKUMA-HAX:
Well this phase is going to suck if nobody even considers the high vote getter’s opinion, then he turns up clean all over again.
Aidebit wanted to vote Soviet. Nobody voted Sovi3t. Nobody today wants to vote Soviet.
3SL wants to vote TCJones. Nobody wants to vote Co-Jones?
AC is a lot different as people do want to vote 3SL, where he wants us to vote.
Pie and co-jones are on my suspicious list for tomorrow, along with Blindknagg depending on how he votes tonight…but we’ll cross that bridge when we get there
Cross it now, in case you die. Why am I a suspect in your eyes?
If I die, i’ll get a last gasp anyway. I guess it would be an easy overlook by a mafia member who didn’t have the luxury of that sort of thing.
Seriously tho, I mentioned my suspicion of you yesterday because of that bs “cold-numbers” plan or whatever. I didn’t waste time reading it. Then you jumped on Aidebit when you saw what was happening…hmph sort of reminiscent of what you’re doing right now to me. Honestly why would you cast you’re vote for me, not even listening to what i had to say for myself in defense of AC’s sketchy “case” against me.
Yep, you didn’t waste time reading it, and you didn’t waste time following up to see I’d set a trap.
You’re definitely my choice to die today.
ok, thanks for reiterating that i guess. Seeing as how you already cast you’re vote before actually listening to anything I had to say though, saying I’m your choice is somewhat redundant.

pietastic:
3rdSTRikeLOVE:
pietastic:
3rdSTRikeLOVE:
WTF-AKUMA-HAX:
Well this phase is going to suck if nobody even considers the high vote getter’s opinion, then he turns up clean all over again.
Aidebit wanted to vote Soviet. Nobody voted Sovi3t. Nobody today wants to vote Soviet.
3SL wants to vote TCJones. Nobody wants to vote Co-Jones?
AC is a lot different as people do want to vote 3SL, where he wants us to vote.
Pie and co-jones are on my suspicious list for tomorrow, along with Blindknagg depending on how he votes tonight…but we’ll cross that bridge when we get there
Cross it now, in case you die. Why am I a suspect in your eyes?
If I die, i’ll get a last gasp anyway. I guess it would be an easy overlook by a mafia member who didn’t have the luxury of that sort of thing.
Seriously tho, I mentioned my suspicion of you yesterday because of that bs “cold-numbers” plan or whatever. I didn’t waste time reading it. Then you jumped on Aidebit when you saw what was happening…hmph sort of reminiscent of what you’re doing right now to me. Honestly why would you cast you’re vote for me, not even listening to what i had to say for myself in defense of AC’s sketchy “case” against me.
Yep, you didn’t waste time reading it, and you didn’t waste time following up to see I’d set a trap.
You’re definitely my choice to die today.
ok, thanks for reiterating that i guess. Seeing as how you already cast you’re vote before actually listening to anything I had to say though, saying I’m your choice is somewhat redundant.
But I choose you tho.

3rdSTRikeLOVE:
on another note @Blindknagg did you plan on formulating ANY thoughts of your own or are you just going to keep inb4ing and doing what everybody, all the other mafia i mean, does?
I was more suspicious of AC at first but his post made me concider you another valid vote. I’ve seen how valuable he can be for us if he’s civ like in the last game so I’m not entirely sure on where my vote is going.
At the time of my post out of the two of you AC was the one that had started to make some discussion going and laid out why you should be lynched over him while you had been mostly wallflowering or making fluff posts (unless I missed something?) so that’s another reason why I think leaving AC alive for tomorrow may get us somewhere.
ok i can understand if you can’t decide, go with the one that is going to give you the most information. The problem with that thinking is assuming that either one of us will be able to give any information at all if the other one shows up a civ when lynched. It’s already been established how improbable, by AC himself as a matter of fact, it would be to have me and him show up civ. Talking that into account, if we vote wrong today then that’s an automatic lynch ( or even vigi kill isn’t totally out of the question ) the next day. The problem with THAT is why waste time guessing on a 50/50 on which one of of is mafia, when you can just go back and look at the statements made by both parties to make the best guess. I don’t know how in dept you decided to study AC’s “case” against me, but you can’t deny it was at best reaching. In case you didn’t read my response to it…I’m not going to spell it out again. If you can’t understand how he’s trying to play you guys then we’re most likely in trouble anyway.
Spoiler

AlphaCommando:
Spoiler
RadicalFuzz:
- What do you three think of OZ’s post in nighttime? Do you think it was intentional, that is was an accident, that it was a test and he was pushing his luck that he wouldn’t be DQd?
- Alpha, do you feel confident you’ll survive today with Chief & Bious gunning for you?
This shouldn’t even be a question. There can’t be anyone that genuinely believes that OZ would premeditate something like that. That was clearly OZ being OZ. He did say in our game night that he liked being able to get away with the ‘village idiot’ thing, but I don’t believe he would’ve done something that idiotic with malicious intent.
I still don’t believe Bious has any resemblance of a case against me. The Chief has even less. I was genuinely convinced that Bious was testing me last Day phase by trying to scare me into voting someone other than you, but him calling for the Vigi to kill me pretty much disproved that theory.
Vynce:
SoVi3t:
@Vynce - kinda busy, I can elaborate later. Go back and check first few pages of the thread. OZ was trying really hard to lead citizens. I mentioned this and how he was likely my lynch and he goes completely silent and stops leading, and never acknowledges my lynch vote. Even after I cast my vote, he hides in the shadows.
Pie and 3rdstrike looking gels suspect. Also, your questioning leads me to aspect ur looking for an in with citizens after your ending up on a few suspect lists.
AlphaCommando has sure simmered down since his name came up for a lynch. Maybe he’s working on a big plan that’ll bag us some capcoms. (For the fans.)
Shit’s hard when you don’t know if there are any secret roles. For now, I’m going to assume that we only have the roles specified on the first page. But at the same time, I can’t. I did have one plan that involved role-claiming, but without knowing what Mafia have up their sleeves, the plan is too risky.
Just to keep track, this was on page 11
It seems AC has a plan that involves role-claiming ( honestly why do i have to spell this out ) but the risks are too highAlphaCommando:
RadicalFuzz:
I find it intriguing that you’re saying a plan is too risky the game after you literally role-claimed Mafia.
I was waiting to see if anyone else would bring up the plan so that I could tell them how flawed it was, but I may as well elaborate.
Have Cher role-claim and tell everyone Sonny’s investigation results.
Pros:
-We get a confirmation for one dayCons:
-Quincy is forced to protect Cher the entire time, losing us the mix-up we have of Quincy’s protection in the first place
-The confirmed role lives until the end of the day, at which point, Mafia kills them with full knowledge that Quincy is protecting Cher
-If we lose Quincy, we lose Cher
-We don’t get a bundle of confirmations when Sonny dies (which would tie up Mafia kills for a couple of days)
-Cher may accidentally confirm Quincy, leading to his death that nightAt first it was just ‘better not reveal this plan in case there’s a role that counters it’, but after further reflection, the consequences outweighed the benefits. Feel free to elaborate on this tactic to see if there are any more pros and cons/see if there’s a way to minimise the cons, but without knowing any more roles, the plan is too risky.
This was page 15
I guess with suspicions coming at him, it’s time to reveal the planAlphaCommando:
If 3SL turns up Civ, I find it hard to believe that there would be anything I could do to avoid being lynched tomorrow. Hell, even if 3SL turns up Mafia, the suspicion would still be on me as using 3SL as a scapegoat, as you said. Either way, my suspicion is unavoidable, but I want to follow this through to its conclusion.
To answer your question of how certain I am that 3SL is Mafia, I’d stake my life on it. If we assume 3SL is Mafia for the moment, that leaves us with 2 possibilities:
- I’m Civ and my reads were correct. I still probably die tomorrow from all the suspicion I’ve attracted, but I’ve hooked a Mafia and I’ve accomplished something and contributed to the game.
- I’m Mafia and I threw 3SL under the bus. I still probably die tomorrow from suspicion, my plan to throw my comrade under the bus fails, and I’ve let 2 Mafia die instead of 1 by bringing 3SL up.
I suppose my argument here is to let me have the satisfaction of drawing my investigation to a conclusion before I die.
and
AlphaCommando:
The_Chief:
AC the MS paint pics are funny but they weren’t helping us.
Yeah, like I said, I may need to reconsider my plans for the first 3 days in the future. Just because the later days are more important than the first couple of days doesn’t mean I shouldn’t treat these first days seriously. I hoped that my investigation of 3SL would prove that I can take the game seriously whilst still having a bit of fun, but on reflection, the fun posts only really served as a distraction from the point I was trying to make.
both on page 16
It seems to me that AC in softly insinuating that he himself is either Sonny or Cher, at least setting up bread crumbs for later just in case his case against me is successful. Anyway, it’s obvious bullspit if you ask me.When I said that I would most likely be voting for co-jones tonight, it was before I was aware of how fast this bandwagon started by the BIGGEST suspect from yesterday was growing. So in the spirit of self-preservation as well as in attempt to vote of our first mafia this game…
Lynch AlphaCommando

3rdSTRikeLOVE:
pietastic:
3rdSTRikeLOVE:
pietastic:
3rdSTRikeLOVE:
WTF-AKUMA-HAX:
Well this phase is going to suck if nobody even considers the high vote getter’s opinion, then he turns up clean all over again.
Aidebit wanted to vote Soviet. Nobody voted Sovi3t. Nobody today wants to vote Soviet.
3SL wants to vote TCJones. Nobody wants to vote Co-Jones?
AC is a lot different as people do want to vote 3SL, where he wants us to vote.
Pie and co-jones are on my suspicious list for tomorrow, along with Blindknagg depending on how he votes tonight…but we’ll cross that bridge when we get there
Cross it now, in case you die. Why am I a suspect in your eyes?
If I die, i’ll get a last gasp anyway. I guess it would be an easy overlook by a mafia member who didn’t have the luxury of that sort of thing.
Seriously tho, I mentioned my suspicion of you yesterday because of that bs “cold-numbers” plan or whatever. I didn’t waste time reading it. Then you jumped on Aidebit when you saw what was happening…hmph sort of reminiscent of what you’re doing right now to me. Honestly why would you cast you’re vote for me, not even listening to what i had to say for myself in defense of AC’s sketchy “case” against me.
Yep, you didn’t waste time reading it, and you didn’t waste time following up to see I’d set a trap.
You’re definitely my choice to die today.
ok, thanks for reiterating that i guess. Seeing as how you already cast you’re vote before actually listening to anything I had to say though, saying I’m your choice is somewhat redundant.
But I choose you tho.
LOL, again I understand that. I understood it 14 hours ago when you said this

Underestimate AC at your own peril, I guess.
I didn’t lock in for AC yet. Shifting to:
**Lynch: 3rdstrikelove. **
I just don’t understand the need to present that like it’s new information when I was just trying to understand you’re reasoning behind the original decision in the first place. ( again without hearing ANYTHING that I might have to say about it ) you’re not making yourself look any better when you do stuff like this pie
Damn it, I just realized i got trolled a little lol. touche sir

]Are we really going to be convinced to vote for MP?
You think so?
Obviously. Anyone who has read MP’s posts and mine will clearly see how fishy he’s looking.
I don’t really have too much else to contribute for now, @Bious can you holla at me when you get back on. There’s something I need to ask you about.

Contributors:
SoVi3t**Players that are not helping ** = Wallflowers:
3rdSTRikeLOVE
Combo_Knight
Cyntalan
GodotsRevenge
Oerba
RECESSIONTIME
Skizz
The Co-JonesCivilians that want to help us win will work together.
Any civilian that isn’t helping is a problem. Something as simple as sharing insight on a particular person or topic can be huge. Only mafia would shy away from helping civs.
Please help?
Sov turned into a wallflower for a big outside the game reason mentioned, but I was looking at him in that last list already.
DukeC wanted a role claim back there nearly, Blindknagg let him off but that is something I have to due-lly consider among these people for something else.
I’m okay with some people having a PM and we are not the gifted role’d gold standard players again. At least there’s only 1 gossip corner and not half a dozen. Ya’ll still having pretzel leglocks over there watching the “sexodus bytches” tapes, sexodus bytch tape? bytch sexotape? You guys would know more, so share.
But definitely, don’t just make it that easy on the Mafia and even worse helping them hide among the very quiet, never have to vote publicly, and not do your duty as a Civ as part of a big team.

Skizzz:
GodotsRevenge:
The fact that only two or three people have mentioned me so far proves that wallflowers need to be questioned and analyzed more.
When did you put in your vote for 3SL?
When I was 100% sure that he wasn’t going to start playing/posting.
I’m wrong a lot.
Hey, mister 1 post every 5 pages.
Can you grab the did not vote last time list, and contribute that.
Then, what do you think we should do about a player with all CAPS in his name?
Im surprised at the lack of role claims so far… only 2?
The game is designed for y’all to make up whatever role you want to be and claim it. Who would dispute it?
I’d perma-hate Kaz if y’all did though.

Im surprised at the lack of role claims so far… only 2?
The game is designed for y’all to make up whatever role you want to be and claim it. Who would dispute it?
I’d perma-hate Kaz if y’all did though.
I wasn’t gonna post because of my stupidity but, kaz did mention that there’s other roles that were PM’d but will not be known publicly.

Just reflecting on the whole jones role claim thing. The best case scenario is that he’s telling the truth and then what? He’s already admitted to not reading the tread or know what’s going on. So that would put him high on the mafia’s hit list for tonight. If we get a botched lynch today, that’s essentially THREE civ kills in a day, asuming he uses his “role” of course. Unless we were to believe him and wrap up the medic’s role on him tonight to avoid losing a bunch of civs. Suspicious
On the other hand, maybe he just wants a target on his back to draw eyes away from on of the more important roles. I just don’t understand how he could feel any particular role or player was in danger of getting killed tonight, so that idea is offer exclusive as a counter argument to the best case situation.Third possibility is a bit more dangerous. Suspicions of AC are being carried over from day one, and Mafia should be fully aware of the possibility if not guaranteed lynching of AC today. Which incidentally has me hunting for mafia in the people who were jumping on AC before the bandwagon was allowed to get rolling. In the midst of confusion, the Mafia will try to do the inception thing.
The was I see it, Co_jones has pretty much nullified his own role by RCing, if he ever had a role to begin with. On the what I would say is the more likely side ( solely based on my paranoid thinking ) this is a brave Mafia move to get us to do something stupid. Even though it’s most likely not going to have any bearing on the vote today, I’ll most likely be voting for co-jones on principle.
Huh…interesting post. What’s the vote of voting on principle? Better yet, why announce that your voting on principle? If anything you should’ve just said that you’re voting TCJ and not said why you’re voting him and seen if you could get any odd responses. In the case that you’re killed and you’re mafia, voting TCJ would probably be the best choice for you since hardly, if anyone, is voting him. Gives the civ the least information if you will.
I don’t want to get lynched no. I’ll probably either put in my resignation soon or get DQ’d, so why waste the vote? I wasn’t able to print out my birth certificate yesterday or today, because the local library is closed because of the roads being covered in ice (and, it seems, our car). It’ll be open tomorrow and my future’ll be set. Probably going to aim for the Nuclear program, simply because I’ll be promoted to an E-4 after basic training and all the schooling. 500$ a month difference between an E-1 and an E-4.
On another note. LOL at me being an alt of someone else. I’m actually kinda insulted about that insinuation.

The_Chief:
Im surprised at the lack of role claims so far… only 2?
The game is designed for y’all to make up whatever role you want to be and claim it. Who would dispute it?
I’d perma-hate Kaz if y’all did though.
I wasn’t gonna post because of my stupidity but, kaz did mention that there’s other roles that were PM’d but will not be known publicly.
Right but no one knows what the other roles are. Unless someone makes up a role that just happens to be identical to one Kaz made… it could be a problem. For example, you role claimed and gave a description of your role. How can I disprove what you say? You can reword it however you need to to fit your goal.
Duke is Mafia, and ac is starting to look like it too.
I’ll stake my reputation on it.
I have this feeling that oz is civilian no matter how much I want to believe he’s Mafia.
If we lynch 3sl today I will be pushing for duke tomorrow 100%.