You mean why am I spending time looking at the lies of a confirmed mafia and trying to find out how his words can lead us to sniff out more mafia and/or figure out who to trust?

With the info I dug up I found at least 3 guys I can sort of trust going forward and in a game of deception that is a huge windfall.

@kaz
@augustus
@alphacommando

How do you 3 feel about WAH? Hopefully I’ve convinced other people here that these 4 should FOR THE TIME BEING be off limits.

That’s nice, but there’s also three others you can trust because the UC/Spy confirmed they were town-sided. As far as I’m concerned there’s a enormous amount of unconfirmed players.

I think it’s very likely that HAX is civilian. I’ve gone through his posts - not really reading them of course - and noticed that there were too many interactions and questions thrown around between him and Pimp Willy to assume that they were on the same team. When HAX and I were both Mafia, we pretty much had zero interaction (until that one mess began). Probably not the best argument in his defense, but I’ll stick to it for now.

You’re dead tonight unfortunately @synonym is silenced until next day phase, and @exodus is dead so the only players who I can confidently say can be trusted at all are those 3 I named and maybe WAH too, which is huge at this early stage of the game, and blindknagg…I’m pulling a kaz here because I feel he may be dirty, but I have no evidence so support it so he isn’t on my radar at the moment.

@ItzJustRellik
@Saitsu
@Shinkuu Tatsumaki
@cyntalan
@The Co-jones
@augustus
@aidebit
@Combo_Knight
@sumazndude
@oerba
@recessiontime
@blindknagg

You guys are the wall flowers this game. I’d like each of you to pick the player on this list you suspect the most and tell us why you suspect them over the others.

Oerba has been dead for a few phases, Oz, and I’d disagree with Augustus, Blindknagg and Saitsu being on that list.

I definitely suspect… actually, this is a wallflower list. It’s easier to suspect people who’ve been posting more, in my opinion. But, Cyntalan did a suspect move, coming out of wallflower-ish-ness after WAH suspected him

And yeah, SAD, I feel you, I barely have enough time because winter break is over.

I am so offended.

Oerba is already dead though (night one vigi kill).(ninja’d by aidebit)

CK wanting to pool his votes on the popular target of the day and him being so quiet seems fishy but I don’t got much more on him than that.

Augustus was the one that I suspected the most just up until recently before you pointed out that PW and Bious been pointing him out as mafia.

Jones locking in on AC long before the deadline and not giving a reason to why is suspicious imo.

Pie and Cyntalan are others that I have been suspicious of for some time. Primarily Cynt who have most of the time only come out to defend himself against posts directed at him and arguing with WAH unless I’ve missed some post from him that doesn’t follow this pattern? Not sure what to think about him being busy and all though.

Those that I trust to not be mafia out of those that are unconfirmed/“soft confirmed” are you Oz, AC and WAH.

I personally don’t like @oerba. Nothing personal. Just a general Mafia gamely dislike. :coffee:

Oh, my bad. You DEAD!

Still don’t like ya’. :coffee:

:smile:

Man not even when Oerba is dead he’s allowed to catch a break. dances on his grave

That’s almost how I feel about @Cyntalon. Don’t even get em started on him. :tup:

Truth be told, they’re all the same. I don’t even know who’s been talking more than one of the others. Also, oerba’s dead

Vynce, come on. Let’s be real. You’re a vet of this game, and I think you know the rules of this game make it easier for mafia to sniff people out. IIRC, this is the first game we’ve had where the enforcer works as a detective for the mafia. I was pretty far off last game, and still consider myself to be knocking off the rust so to speak. We’ve killed Pimp Willy and Bious, two vets who people should have also been afraid of. Are you saying that They wouldn’t have been capable of those reads? Are you saying that you’re not capable of those reads?

UC got sniffed out, but then again, what dummy is going to think to look for roles among those who are actively sticking out their necks? There’s a certain psychology that people have playing this game, and I keep saying time and time again - we need to start discussing these people who aren’t talking. There’s someone hiding there that will keep picking us off while we lynch people that are helpful to us winning the game.

On another note, If I were a wallflower, I’d be more afraid of you - you’re capable of snagging up people to vote with you. Other than OZ and maybe Exodus at certain points, who else will/has sided with me so far? I’m civ also, and I’m not playing OZ. I trust him because I trust my gut, and my gut proved me right about Willy and Bious.

Other than one post he made that made me bust out laughing, I feel bad for admitting I have no clue what HAX is even saying :rofl:

Several hours left and we still have no direction. @Vynce, I’m wondering which way you think we ought to go?

UC says we start with you. What exactly have you done to contribute to the game, other than play imitation The Chief? How do we know you’re not godfather? If the mafia doesn’t enforce him tonight and he investigates you, you show up innocent even if you’re godfather. We should take that with a grain of salt. Yet, I don’t think your behavior thus far suggests you’re clean.

@kaz You and PW knew I was dirty, the one time I was. I’ll never forget it.

OZ backed off his suspicion of me. That’s about the last straw, for me. I’ll probably be casting my vote for him today.

…Or Combo Knight

I might go for a Combo or Cyntalan lynch depending on what happens today.

…Nope. Not explaining this shit again.

Well you’re either a bad Mafia or a fool, but at least you aren’t a liar.

His lack of understanding how certain roles work and his lack of hesitation to antagonise me point to uncooperative Civ. Having said that, I wouldn’t have a problem lynching him if that’s where the rest of the thread were throwing their votes.


Think I’m gonna go back, look at the voting tallies and find someone I don’t like that’s acting suspicious that voted for me.

Post edited by Missing Person on About 13 hours ago

Front page. No links to daily write-ups, FGC vs. Illuminati URL still broken. Did the Mafia request something changed? Time to plug in the toaster and get my Jesus comb.