I don’t think so. If Jailer turns, that information ends up in the wrong hands.
lol got damn, I came to post about that just now.
I accuse him after that day one gaff, send a vote his way, then he gets put in jail. Hrmmm. I need to think about this.
Or it means Azure is the mayor.
Losing detective this early is going to really hurt 
Can you explain your vote for me or is it the same “you just don’t care” responses?
Will you be building a case against MP tomorrow?
Ready for some Jesus Toast?
The vote tallies for The Co-Jones are listed in alphabetical order. None of the others are, but the votes for MP are close. The votes for me are in alphabetical order I guess, too, but there were only two.
Looking at the vote results, I have a lot of cases to build. MP will be included.
Van Helsing and the Doctor should have a much smaller pool of suspects to attack as well.
What are your plans Alpha?
Well I was going to question Azure on going back on his word in regards to lynching CJ, but given today’s town hall results, that would warrant unnecessary suspicion on Azure.
I haven’t decided whether to scrutinise the No Lynchers or the No Voters tomorrow. I’m leaning towards the No Lynchers, since the No Voters may take care of themselves.
it seems pretty par for the course so far for a day one. Personally i’m going to avoid lynching someone based off a read today because those are always paper thin at this point in the game
lynch: The Co-Jones
and of course i would make the post after the deadline… fml
What’s crazy to me is there’s 21 (now 20) civs and the detective still gets lynched.
How can 3 mafia members convince people to follow their lead? Amazing. I’m actually impressed.
Technically both mafia squads would want civs to blindly lynch wallflowers so we could say it was 6 people working in unison. In a way that logic would help mafia find other mafia in order to avoid attacking each other.
Can you see?
@highlulu Have you gone through the entire thread now? If so, who are you going to be your main suspects next day phase?
I need to go back and check out who hopped on the Lynch TCJ train really quick once it started, definitely gonna find a monster there
I was disheartened until I realized jailed!= silenced. So, it suits me fine.
I believe Alpha was the first to bring up his name and it was for good reason. However, the issue isn’t that lynching wallflowers is dumb, its lynching wallflowers in this particular game setup is dumb.
People think oh, lets clear the dead weight, but then as we clear wallflower #4 on day 4, mafia is now able to kill/convert 5/6 civs per night.
How exactly does that help us? @Icege?
You happened to be toon link on the brawl roster.
Since day one is a straw reach, I decided to give every player a listing on the brawl roster and I would chose based upon the first choice selected by the Random character select.
I wouldn’t be so sure. If you’re a smart monster, and you feel confident a civ is going to get lynched, why throw yourself into the mob?
If they felt it necessary to get enough votes for it to come to pass, then yes. Especially if they had to stack the votes one way instead of another.
I’m a little confused on the advantages of lynching active players over wallflowers (even though this probably isn’t what you’re suggesting). Is there a higher chance that more active players are Mafia than wallflowers? From what I’ve seen in the past, it looks like wallflower Mafia make it further than outspoken Mafia. Avoiding targeting wallflowers also encourages less talking from people in order to look less suspicious, which limits the amount of information we receive.
I’m not saying lynching wallflowers is always the way to go, but in the instance that we have little information to go on, it seems (to me) like we’re more likely to find a Mafia hiding in the wallflowers than in the active users.
I always put them in alphabetical order. I put The Chief after DG in one line accidently (I was doing it fast, it was 9:00 am and I had a 9:00 meeting), even the people who got 1 vote are in alphabetical order. I never reveal who voted in what order via the results. No Lynch was my bad, I did put ICege in the wrong spot.
But no jesus toast here.
I wasn’t trying to implicate MP in saying that, though I realize I did. It also begs the question, how many eggs will you risk placing in one basket?