Ok. time for my wild speculation, I don’t know if I’ll be able to talk next day or not (for one reason or another), so I’ll put this out in the open. If I’m way off base, well then I guess I deserve to go
I think that Noodlehead is Magneto. Let me go over the reasons why
Firstly, I’m going on the assumption Magneto is a Marvel, even though he is on the Capcom PM, he wins only if the Marvels win. Why? Look at all the roles, he is listed with the Marvels. Nowhere on his card does it say he wins if the Capcoms win like it does with taskmaster. There is nothing to indicate he can win in any way other than Marvels winning. A lot of people seem to be under the assumption that he can choose sides or something, but I don’t get that from the rules at all. However, he can’t actually role claim. So, with that being said…
-
If you were the mafia, and you had to silence somebody day 1, who would make most sense? How about the guy who knew all your identities. Magneto knows who each of the 5 capcoms on the PM are, I’d have to guess they were discussing roles and who had what. Through process of elimination, you’d have to know which of you was Magneto. But the problem is, they can’t do anything about it, because if they kill him in any way other than a lynch, then he will get a Will sent out with all the Capcom names, effectively ending the game.
-
Knowing this, Magneto makes a perfect night 1 silence. Because Magneto can steer the game in the right direction, help people with inside information, etc you would not want him talking until you can deal with him.
-
Noodle’s silence seemed to catch everyone off guard. If he is indeed Magneto, it makes sense wouldn’t it? And he’s been silenced, so he can’t help us out at all to clear anything up.
Now, did Noodle leave any hints that maybe he was something special like this?
I Find this post odd:
From somebody who knows his way around a Mafia game, notice how he intentionally gets the role count mixed up? 7 core mafia… but really there are only 6. Magneto isn’t core mafia, he is not mafia at all. Was he just unsure on the role count? Or was he posting this in hope somebody caught his slip up?
Same thing with the “we” thing. Noodle wouldn’t make that mistake on accident, and even though I’m convinced it was taken out of context, perhaps that was his intent.
Hell, look at the color scheme he uses on page 1 to talk about roles, RED and PURPLE. Magneto colors. He repeats this every time he is talking about Marvel and Capcom roles on the first few pages. He also manages to talk about Magneto roles a lot ,asking SWB Questions on it, seemingly fixated on the role up until he got silenced.
Now, assuming that the Magneto role is correct, what would that mean? Well, he was hesitant to put a vote onto GCL (turned out innocent), and when I pressed him for who we should vote for, he put in
But he wouldn’t put a vote in on Exodus, I don’t know if he’s nemesis (although Nemesis would actually probably still give magneto his last will with all the names I think?)
So, I don’t know, if he is Magneto, he can’t role claim. But he should be able to answer some questions easy enough:
-
Do you think we should lynch Exodus? If he’s dirty, it would be a good way to prove you right…
-
Is it a good idea for Ghost Rider to give you a visit the next night phase?
And if I’m way off base with this later on, you can all look at me and laugh… because at least I’m going out in a flame of glory!