hmmm why do people keep saying lynch innactives? I would think innactives would more than likely be civs. I am curious to see how this game unfolds as it goes on since this is the first time I have played and am still not sure how it works.
As for the carpenter thing. if he does get targeted cant the black guy sacrifice himself?
[media=youtube]m1bLXk6UVts[/media]
Throwing out the suggestion to vote for inactives is a good way to get some scum to possibly out themselves, as it’s an easy sure-fire method to play safe if that’s what is all agreed upon. Also, last game, I believe one mafia was booted for inactivity, but correct me if I’m wrong.
Only on the day phase. Night phase he’d have to be protected by the nurse. And once again, this is all relying on the fact that the carpenter is who he says he is.
Bottomline, no lynch is a horrible choice for first night. Why is this brought up every match?
Because there are new people every match?
Well, I do feel somewhat inclined to remind you guys that just because I wear an eye patch, doesn’t mean I’m inherently evil. -_-
This is SRK. Everyone is black until proven otherwise, meaning the black guy will blend right in.
I got my “eye” on you DRD. 
Nah, I believe the two people who were booted (Papa Rhino and Serin) were both civilians, and almost prompted some of us to just give up. So far, 2-3 people haven’t posted yet. Anyone know if they’ve been posting in other threads?
I vote to lynch inactives due to the fact that later on, civs need to have good solid information/theories, and inactives don’t really help in that sense. And MAFIA tend to be inactive to not draw attention to themselves.
We go through this every game. I can’t post from work, except on my phone and signal here is terrible. I haven’t read through the thread but as always, if you’re thinking no lynch, that’s a bad idea.
I agree for a Night 1 lynch. It seems the smartest thing to do
I’m with sovi3t lynching inactives is all we can really do, every fuckin game someone makes up some bullshit idea to lynch some poor civ and everyone gets duped into it. Well not this game. Lynching inactives who will be deadweight later on is the only argument anyone can have at this early point where we have 0 information.
I’m at a con and got horrible signal too, so I’ll go with whoever the majority goes for (which is hopefully someone who hasn’t posted yet.)
Just a reminder to everyone, I always check in I just dont post everytime (But I’ll try and change that haha)
Since thats me it seems like everyone else is in but busy at this time so it looks like its gonna be more of a random lynch this cycle
So who we voting for? I will still be in bed at the time the vote ends, so I gotta do this before I go to sleep. And I don’t wanna be ‘that guy’ who does the first lynch vote
So who we voting for? I will still be in bed at the time the vote ends, so I gotta do this before I go to sleep. And I don’t wanna be ‘that guy’ who does the first lynch vote
Who’s the inactives? Might as well get the “dead” weight out first.
If I’m counting correct, everyone’s at least checked in.
I know, it’s shocking.
Dramatix hasn’t posted in this thread yet.
This is true…
So kill Dramatix and hope this idiot isn’t an important role?