Srk mafia game viii: phoenix wright - judge, jury, and executioner [ finished ]

[RadicalFuzz]

Cyntalan is Guilty

Looking at the lynch records from yesterday and the mafia’s choice of action last night, Cyntalan has the most to gain from the No Kill.

[Saitsu]

Unless you think I’m Mafia by trying to push the Lynch on DRD rather than Immaculate. But I fucking dare you to try and call that one.

I wrote it up earlier without posting it. I might even add to it.

The Blame Game has gone crazy.

I want you dead.
What are you the narrator?
Then I will be remaining as the biggest sig player left.
+You also like every topic anywhere on SRK better than this one.

Pretend you’re playing the game more than Duckie is and if you are then why bandwagon so fast? This is your only move the whole game. You can do it, just like you have before, without the grandstanding.

I’d rather just be normally useless than spending day after day non-voting and begging people to kill me just because.

Feel free to kill me though, I have no problem with that either. I’ll be honest, the Mafia game isn’t as fun as I thought it’d be. And with E3 going on, Ragna’s right, I’d much rather be in any other thread but this one.

But I’m also not a bitch and I will finish what I started.

And Ragna, I’ve been a possible Lynch target since Day 1, what makes your target oh so special?

[WTF-AKUMA-HAX]

No GCL last gasp by the way? Granted he has no reason to help us from how much we crapped on him. Serves us right.

[The_Chief]

Saitsu finally suiting up to play on the lowest hanging carrot after not even making an attempt to put in some work after he was up to the stand and right after I bring you up as a possible lynch target last day phase? Fuck outta here; I’m not buying this shit at all.

Saitsu is GUILTY

You voted Cyntalan when the GCL wagon was rolling. Vote Cyntalan this time. We can double back on Saitsu later.

[Vynce]

No GCL last gasp by the way? Granted he has no reason to help us from how much we crapped on him. Serves us right.

Yeah…I disagree.

GREAT COW LORD WAS A BIG HELP

I’d rather not have lynched a marvel, but shit.

[SSRagna]

And Ragna, I’ve been a possible Lynch target since Day 1, what makes your target oh so special?

Really, I just find the sequence of events that took place a little too coincidental for my liking. Normally you’d be right, as a target there probably are other people that would also be viable targets (like Cyntalan, Immaculate, possibly PW) but the fact that you decided to go after DRD as if your imbalance of posting things that irrelevant to the game at hand compared to talk on the game itself is any better, put you at the top for me.

[WTF-AKUMA-HAX]

I can’t always gather your meaning. kind of key, in this.

I wrote myself into a frenzy with thinking over choosing Immaculate last Lynch phase and probably tuned everyone out. Few people wanted to know the reasoning or dispute it. I don’t know how much that means they’re civ or mafia.

Its great they are willing to vote against him today!
-for no reason I mentioned though. >:[

[Saitsu]

And Ragna, I’ve been a possible Lynch target since Day 1, what makes your target oh so special?

Really, I just find the sequence of events that took place a little too coincidental for my liking. Normally you’d be right, as a target there probably are other people that would also be viable targets (like Cyntalan, Immaculate, possibly PW) but the fact that you decided to go after DRD as if your imbalance of posting things that irrelevant to the game at hand compared to talk on the game itself is any better, put you at the top for me.

I was just tired of DRD’s crap. I had already shown my dislike days earlier but at that time there were bigger fish to fry.

As of now, he’s still being a pain in the ass and we’re coming off a possible Mafia No Kill. Since the impossibility of the Medic getting that move right, it’s definitely such which suggests a position of extreme weakness. I actually want to see their next move at this point since this is a bit erratic and unexpected. One thing to do a No Kill, another thing to make it look extremely obvious.

Thus, a good time to call DRD’s bluff now that he’s pretty much irreparably ruined his ability to actually play this game and any other in the future. Only way he hasn’t is if he’s Mafia.

With that, plus someone actually voting to deal with him finally, I figured it was a good time to finally go in.

Besides, if I stayed on the sidelines forever I would be an early Lynch in every future game as well for being a worthless civ or a potential Mafia threat.

Again though, feel free to Lynch me if that’s your reasoning. I got no problem with it.

[The_Chief]

You’re going against your logic.

Since we’re only a little more than an hour away, looks like the lynch target for today is more or less confirmed. With that in mind, I don’t think it’ll be a problem if I place my vote elsewhere.

Cyntalan is GUILTY

‘Voting elsewhere’ isn’t gonna help us. Vote Cyntalan.

[SSRagna]

You voted Cyntalan when the GCL wagon was rolling. Vote Cyntalan this time. We can double back on Saitsu later.

I’ve had Cyntalan as a possible suspect for a long time, so if it looks like we’re going to ring him in here I’m down for that.

My reasoning for placing my vote for you is pretty set in stone, Saitsu; but this is also a team game so I’m willing to back off today for the good of the whole.

Saitsu is Innocent

Cyntalan is GUILTY

[sikwidit]

how does mafias no lynch help out cyntalan.
Does it still help him out if it was a real nurse.

i think cyntalan is actually in a better position if itis indeed a no lynch. if mafia killed chief last night rather than no kill him then we would heavily suspect cyntalan since chief was the first to go in on him.

Godotsrevenge also had a good point on everyone agreeing. Even if the real nurse did protect chief last night.
what do they get out of it to pretend that it was a no kill? maybe so we still have to have some doubt about chief? That would be the only reason I can think of.

chief you are one of the ones i do actually trust so please give me your reasons on voting cyntalan over someone else

[WTF-AKUMA-HAX]

At first i did it because I was bored lol. But the real reason behind it was to get the mafia to target me that night to save the other civilians and our roles. That didn’t pan out. So I had no choice but to keep the mask on until the next night phase, hoping they would kill me again. But that didn’t happen. It wasn’t really convincing to begin with.

Pimp was right the whole time.

The main plan was to die the night after the role claim by mafia. Everything went to shit lol

You were right about all Mafia bandwagoning on a player they know is Civ. It sucks for you that we have to take that against you in some capacity too.

As well your still being alive does have the possibility of also being Mafia. You’re happy to be alive but are only discussing your own innocence. Sucks for you again we have to keep you on the table and you can’t fall back into the rest of the team and play from there. We have to work with what we have as evidence.

You pleaded to keep you alive last voting to see some big sparks fly. Here’s today, no Vigi kill, “Great the other (Real) Vigi is probably dead!”

That’s not so great. Unless you’re Mafia. I still can’t put the likelihood of your odds at being Mafia, but who’s your target for this day phase lynch vote? You can’t lynch yourself for this game’s rules if I remember that right.

---

[BullDancer]

Evaluating the situation…
#Lynch DaRabidDuckie

I strongly encourage yall to unlynch Cyntalan… just because…

[RadicalFuzz]

The mafia’s No Kill helps Cyntalan because it gets people talking about other lynch targets. Vote-wise Cyntalan was next in line to be lynched after GCL. If the mafia wants to disrupt that they can No Kill and bring up a lot of doubt about somebody to distract us. It’s worked before. Bious revealing he’s mafia distracted us from Hecatom and we lost information because of that. I didn’t see that until after it was too late and I don’t want the same thing to happen again.

Assuming this was a No Kill on Chief, it’s likely the Mafia has fewer members than I suspected. Which raises the possibility of a night kill having actually been a sacrifice. Of all the night kills, the only person who was marked for death was Hecatom. It’s worth considering that he may have been mafia and was sacrificed at night because he would’ve been lynched the next day.

[Cyntalan]

Wait, you didn’t even question me. You just said you suspect me. How am I supposed to respond, or even retaliate to that? It could be construed as retaliatory if you had voted for me. You didn’t.

I even said last day phase you were on my suspects list, along with Pimp Willy. Of course I’m going to go based off my suspect list for my lynch vote. What else am I supposed to do?

“Well, I really suspect Cyntalan and maybe PW are mafia, so I’ll just vote for Vynce and hope these Vlasic Pickles are really crunchy and taste like flannel pants.”

GTFO with your paranoia. That’s not really helping your case.

Question, suspect, you’re arguing semantics here. I post my list, you pop in and start a bandwagon in the face of two already in play, both of which we still suspect is mafia for one reason or another (cheap ploy gone stale, or cheap role claim gone stupid). Seems sketch.

I, for one, think DRD just doesn’t wanna be here, to which I would rather him just petition NoodleHead to remove him from play now instead of sitting here wasting our time thinking “to lynch, or not to lynch”. Immac seems like he’s getting off easy on this shit and people are buying it.

[sikwidit]

i dont think it gets people talking about other lynch votes because we havent. It just really made everyone go in on cyntalan more. We also cant ignore that it is possible that chief is mafia and no killed himself, i doubt this but it is possible. i will have to go back and read but something is pushing me away from cyntalan right now.

[WTF-AKUMA-HAX]

Damn, I forgot all about this.

I can get rid of one distraction here to help us focus on bigger fish.

Someone else brought it up last voting phase. The first person to follow my (bad) day 1 lead was Bious’ only vote. “Man Saitsu is Guilty as fuck”

That clears Saitsu 99%

If Bious was even more Inept
-Didn’t read the rules
-Didn’t remember who was on his team
-Didn’t care & just didn’t like your face Saitsu

---

[The_Chief]

how does mafias no lynch help out cyntalan.
Does it still help him out if it was a real nurse.

i think cyntalan is actually in a better position if itis indeed a no lynch. if mafia killed chief last night rather than no kill him then we would heavily suspect cyntalan since chief was the first to go in on him.

Godotsrevenge also had a good point on everyone agreeing. Even if the real nurse did protect chief last night.
what do they get out of it to pretend that it was a no kill? maybe so we still have to have some doubt about chief? That would be the only reason I can think of.

chief you are one of the ones i do actually trust so please give me your reasons on voting cyntalan over someone else

Because I don’t believe the lynch will be successful.

His name has come up in every Day phase for votes and each time the thread conversation miraculously turned away from him.

I don’t believe Mafia will vote for him.

[SSRagna]

Damn, I forgot all about this.

I can get rid of one distraction here to help us focus on bigger fish.

Someone else brought it up last voting phase. The first person to follow my (bad) day 1 lead was Bious’ only vote. “Man Saitsu is Guilty as fuck”

---

No…it wasn’t Bious. That was Crotchpuncha. I even quoted the post that said it. Bious voted for Oerba that phase.

[Saitsu]

Wait, you didn’t even question me. You just said you suspect me. How am I supposed to respond, or even retaliate to that? It could be construed as retaliatory if you had voted for me. You didn’t.

I even said last day phase you were on my suspects list, along with Pimp Willy. Of course I’m going to go based off my suspect list for my lynch vote. What else am I supposed to do?

“Well, I really suspect Cyntalan and maybe PW are mafia, so I’ll just vote for Vynce and hope these Vlasic Pickles are really crunchy and taste like flannel pants.”

GTFO with your paranoia. That’s not really helping your case.

Question, suspect, you’re arguing semantics here. I post my list, you pop in and start a bandwagon in the face of two already in play, both of which we still suspect is mafia for one reason or another (cheap ploy gone stale, or cheap role claim gone stupid). Seems sketch.

I, for one, think DRD just doesn’t wanna be here, to which I would rather him just petition NoodleHead to remove him from play now instead of sitting here wasting our time thinking “to lynch, or not to lynch”. Immac seems like he’s getting off easy on this shit and people are buying it.

I would definitely much rather have DRD removed and blacklisted for a couple of games rather than being forced to waste a Lynch on him. Unfortunately, I don’t think NH will go for that.