I was hoping people think it would be a “dumb noob” slip up and the mafia would take the bait.
Our best lead right now is the Mafia’s No Kill. We need to figure out what they were trying to accomplish with it. Mafia Theory time:
Let’s pretend that you’re a Mafia member. Day phase just ended and the civs lynched GCL with Cyntalan and Immaculate coming in a far second and third. What do you do that night? Let’s take the two extremes and look at them differently:
-You lost the maximum possible number of players. You started with 7, crotch and Bious puts it down to 5, kaz and lulu dying makes it 3. In this situation, the “score” is 3-16. Which is more valuable, setting up “mixups” by No Killing or killing a civ to make the score 3-15? I’d argue that, in this situation, the mafia would not kill anybody
-You lost the minimum possible number of players. You started with 8, crotch and Bious puts it down to 6.
In this situation, the “scorew” is 6-13. In this scenario, killing a civilian is the more appealing option, as a few wrong lynches can win you the game within a few days
The fact that the mafia used No Kill makes me think fewer Mafia are alive than we expect, they wouldn’t sacrifice kills for mindgames otherwise.
I would change my vote to Cyntalan in sec…
Actually,
Cyntalan is GUILTY
Done. Immaculate lives because of sikwidits post. And I mostly concur with his judgement. Sik, if Immaculate gets killed by Mafia as Vigi, I hope you’re prepared to sif through the shenanigans cause I don’t see what you see in him. Just sayin’.
@Immaculate I think that it was a pretty strong bluff… I’m more sold on DRD than you tbh…
Although yall are both in bad standing…
Because the real vigilante could have easily have killed you if he wanted to…
BullDancer ALWAYS shows up when a vite for Cyntalan is made.
In the words of the long gone DeDesiCanadian…
Seriously?
And before I get called on for liking your post(I like things to mark them as read)…
I just woke up nigga, the fact that you go for Cyntalan on all the day phases has absolutely nothing to do with me…
I don’t trust you or him…
Is there a reason other than making you believe my fake role claim?
Its not like I can vote for him at night.
Go ahead and put in your vote for Cyntalan and be done with it. You won’t have to read my posts about lynching him anymore if he’s dead.
My lucky touch is gone apparently… I’ve voted for one mafia and 2 civs…
I tell you what… if nothing turns up from my lynch current vote, I’ll vote for Cyntalan and stay on it…
I wrote it up earlier without posting it. I might even add to it.
I want you dead.
What are you the narrator?
Then I will be remaining as the biggest sig player left.
+You also like every topic anywhere on SRK better than this one.
Pretend you’re playing the game more than Duckie is and if you are then why bandwagon so fast? This is your only move the whole game. You can do it, just like you have before, without the grandstanding.
Why haven’t any Mafia members argued that there wasn’t a No Kill?
God, it’s unsettling when everybody agrees.
Tired as hell today, but I finally managed to come back and post.
First off, wtf? Did the Medic actually saved a person from the mafia, or did the mafia use the No Kill?
Next, since reading the story progression, I see that: Immaculate is alive, the Vigi did not kill anyone, and Immaculate is a liar! He promised us that he is the Vigi and that he’ll kill someone with his stock last night, but nothing happened. Since he lied about the role claim, I think that is enough to warrant a lynch.
He’s either a mafia, or he’s helping them by false role claim and not helping our cause.
Immaculate is guilty
It’s either him or DRD at this point, since DRD wants out of the game, making it either a mafia tactic, or a not-so-useful civ.
Vynce
2175
I like you as a poster, and I like your posts. I can tell you’re a smart guy. Remember your complaint about no one listening to you, last game?
Be more articulate when posting in here. Just like in the lounge when you occasionally drop an eloquent post on someone to shut them up.
I can’t always gather your meaning. kind of key, in this.
Saitsu finally suiting up to play on the lowest hanging carrot after not even making an attempt to put in some work after he was up to the stand and right after I bring you up as a possible lynch target last day phase? Fuck outta here; I’m not buying this shit at all.
Saitsu is GUILTY
I love this. I question him and he up and throws down a vote for me in retaliation. Quite curious. :rolleyes:
I didn’t even see where you questioned me. I’ll go back.
Wait, you didn’t even question me. You just said you suspect me. How am I supposed to respond, or even retaliate to that? It could be construed as retaliatory if you had voted for me. You didn’t.
I even said last day phase you were on my suspects list, along with Pimp Willy. Of course I’m going to go based off my suspect list for my lynch vote. What else am I supposed to do?
“Well, I really suspect Cyntalan and maybe PW are mafia, so I’ll just vote for Vynce and hope these Vlasic Pickles are really crunchy and taste like flannel pants.”
GTFO with your paranoia. That’s not really helping your case.
Use no Vote
Bandwagon right away (if it worked or didn’t)
Use a lot of F-bombs for support to say you’re believable I guess?
HEY ROUKIE MAFIA, GET SERIOUS!!
Who wants to play future games with people as quiet as Saitsu? And you already have a plan if you let Duckie in and he’s just as busy. Even better to get the day 1 madness of a lynch with no good targets out of the way. But we don’t have to worry about that now for this game.
You want to explain (B) a bit more there.
