This part about the LED’s…
The cheaper LED solution should be the whole point about this stick.
It personally doesn’t make sense to me to take the original PCB and the LED’s out of commission. It’s certainly cheaper to NOT have to replace the original PCB but to have to redo all the button wiring and lose the LED’s at the same?!?!?!?!?!?
(I did enough modding with soldered-button Hori PCB’s to get the whole point about trying to do as little work as possible AND saving a buck when I could.)
I doubt any of us is going to find a cheaper solution for LED’s.
The third-party controller board costs alone kill that notion…
Add to that the cost of the individual button-configured LED’s.
Sure, the original Injustice joystick LED’s are not personalized LED’s but still…!
There’s gotta be a way to integrate an LS-32 type controller without losing the joystick LED, either.
(You just know that’s going to involve a) cutting the plastic LS-32 base somehow; and b) figuring a way to put the LEDs between the top base and just above the joystick micro’s to getaccurate LED response to directional inputs… that’s the problem right there. Your cutting [in the right places] would have to be VERY accurate or a third-market party part solution would have to be made available to take care of this problem…
(This is precisely why I don’t like non-universal joystick designs!)
Paradise Shop, for instance, has replacement hollow LS-32 shafts (you want the short one for a mod on an existing joystick case) AND sells an inexpensive LS-32 clone with 0.187 tabs that’s pretty good. Heck, you could buy a silent mod for the LS-32 and still come out ahead of buying a silent JLF/JLF mod kit! The directionals are the hard part of the joystick LED… That’s a challenge I’m sure a couple of guys (Toodles, jdm, etc.) could figure out. ( => Don’t look at me… I think up ideas but I’m no engineer – and I also don’t have infinite money to waste away parts, either! LOL)
C’est la vie… do whatever makes you feel better or happiest in the end!
This is just some other anonymous shmoe’s opinion.
I skipped this joystick because I wasn’t crazy about the design (Astro City-esque) and artwork ( = I HATE post-52 DC) LED or no LED. I got out of acquiring new Astro City-build cases even before Hori stopped making them. (FYI, the last Hori Astro City joystick was the HRAP 3 Tekken Tag Tournament 2 Prologue joystick.)
I hope this post does not come across as a condemnation of what Darksakul did – that’s his personal project and what he wanted in the end – but it does express some of my concerns about these mods.
I’ve done my share of a mod or two where I felt I went TOO far and changed the character of a joystick too much…