I still do not believe that Seth is unfair. I don’t think Sagat is unfair either. Compared to top tier chars in other games like 3S the top tier in SF4 is not that bad at all. Sagat actually has to do lots of different things in different situations unlike Chun in 3s where all you really need is kara throw and cr.mk. Maybe my evaluation of 3s is bad because I suck at it, but I’m just trying to make an analogy anyway.
And there is a huge difference between being overpowered and ban-worthy. You didn’t just say that Seth was unfair, you basically said that I shouldn’t be allowed to play him because he’s like HDR Akuma unfair. Chars like Yun and Chun in 3s are powerful but that’s just how games turn out. And if anything Seth and Sagat are weaker than Yun and Chun are in 3s.
Allen and raeli already made my arguments for me considering your evidence and Seth being broken.
You and I both know that article doesn’t mean anything. A comment made by one guy at Capcom who didn’t work on the console release.
What do you mean “I started my stubborn shit?” I didn’t yell at you at all. If anything you were the one who got upset. You even said “You can disagree with me, but you’re still wrong.” You didn’t make one real point about how Seth was broken. You even said he has no bad matchups, and that’s just flat out not true. Best poking game in the game? Better than Sim? Please. That’s not even worth addressing. Point is, you got flustered when I disagreed with you and you started saying things that were pretty ridiculous to back up your argument. And that’s how an argument works, one person uses logic to establish something and the other person critiques those points and brings up counterpoints to get a different result. I was never unwilling to change my mind, you just never convinced me.
I’m not even saying Seth isn’t broken. I would love to have Seth be broken so I could ride that shit to the win. But as of right now I can’t say definitively that Seth is broken. Seth gets away with a lot of scrubby things, but he needs it because his footsies and health are ass. Maybe one day I’ll figure out how to make Seth broken and I’ll agree with you, but I just don’t see it. I’m not “lying to myself.” I’d be lying to myself if I agreed with you and apologized just to make this argument go away.
Of course I’m biased. I play Seth. I never said I wasn’t. And I know I’m stubborn. I also know I’m not as good a player as you. But that doesn’t mean that I’m necessarily wrong.
If anything you said in this post was reasonable and made me want to reconsider what you said, this last part just threw all that work out the window. You’ll “make my life in this thread miserable?” That’s really immature Glenn. Now how can anyone read that last part and not get the idea that you have a vendetta against me?
You act like I come in here and say stupid random things every week. I mean, I used to, yeah. But now I only post in Greenland about hookups. I didn’t go out of my way to say that Seth is totally fair. I only responded to your comment in person specifically because you were saying that Seth shouldn’t be allowed in tournaments, which directly affects me.
I’m not going anywhere. You are the only person who has called me out. From all I can tell, everyone else seems to think I’m a pretty chill guy. And no, I’m not here because of my association with Ben. That’s what got me in the door, but it was my ability to improve and bring a unique character to the table that got people to want to play me. You think Rex encourages me because I’m Ben’s friend? Nah, he does it because he wants more competition and he thinks that I have the potential to get better.
Man, I would love to drop this so much. I tried hard to just ignore it, but Glenn brought it up literally like seven times in the last month. I didn’t want to make this personal, I didn’t even want to make it an issue. Like I said before, I just want to play Street Fighter 4.