The question itself is even more troubling for me with this response. Personally, I agree that this quote is a good, general description of how you can expect an average person of that level to play. However, I’ve only come close to 2000pp, and always have immediately lost B rank when achieving it. For 4 years of playing on and off, I’ve hovered between a low of 600-700 pp, and a high of 1500-1900 pp. I believe my reaction is decent, I bait reversals, my footsies are decent, and I have a general knowledge of combos. But when it comes to winning consistently I’m anything but consistent. I’m that guy who steals 100+ pp from someone higher, then donates it away to the charity players everyone else can stomp. I have no real sub, only playing Makoto all of this time.
I believe execution is a factor, but not in a basic sense. Can you not mess up things that will get you punished for? For example, I get someone in Makoto’s corner combo, and I miss the fukiage. They stand up and punish me big on my dropped combo. With little mistakes that cost a lot like this, winning consistently is a sad joke.
When you lose a match, do you know why you lost? Do you generally blame yourself for losing, or do you think you are beat? If you can blame yourself and see the mistakes you made, then you can correct them.
Another thing that I think of is pressure game. How well can you tolerate pressure from an opponent? With your back to the wall, low on health, can you still fight back without cracking? Pressure game s another way I’d rate how good someone is. Knowledge of match ups, and confidence in your skill with your character is a big factor in this to me.
I automatically assume that people with around 2000pp are at least average in those few things.
But long story short, I don’t believe pp is always an accurate way to judge skill. However, it does irk me to know that certain people are winning more than I am when I know the amount of effort I put into the game. I know why I haven’t become a 2000pp player. I make dumb execution errors that get me executed, I have difficulty dealing with certain match ups, and sometimes I get spooked and give up momentum that’s in my favor. Oh…and my biggest sin: not blocking or teching throws when I believe that I am…but I can stuff that into execution as well.