What I’ve seen online –
HRAP 2 SA (PS2 stick with white HRAP plastic base, reflective face plate and all light blue buttons and light blue ball handle; it is the only Hori stick with grey Sanwa start/select buttons; 24mm grey Sanwa pushbuttons specially made for this stick) = $199; it’s an older generation stick but still one of the best ever made; very usable on the PS3 and computers with a good PS2-to-PS3 USB adaptor; people have problems with PS2 sticks because of crummy adaptors, not the PS3 software or the PS2 stick hardware; I bought my PS3 adaptor for my own copy of this stick from Cables4PC on ebay…
Other HRAP 2’s = green and orange editions; generally selling for $150 or more, average is $170; if you’re going to spend at least $150, you might as well get the HRAP 2 SA with full arcade-quality parts unless you hate light blue buttons or have a fetish for spending on different colored buttons, or really, really want to buy different colored upgrade Sanwa pushbuttons; personally, I think the HRAP 2 SA is a better buy than these sticks…
HRAP3 = average closer to $170 online, and remember this stick doesn’t even have Sanwa buttons! Before the supply crunch, you could get one of these sticks for around $90 – some of the more limited versions like the all-white Amazon-Japan version sold for around $30 more… Ironically, the cheaper HRAP3’s online ARE used Amazon-Japan white versions. I’ve seen some online retailers selling the regular black-base production run HRAP3’s for $240 or more… that’s definitely overpriced for a stick that doesn’t have arcade-quality pushbuttons…
MadCatz TE = $150 if you bought it at a game store around the SF IV launch… After that, expect to pay at least $200 online for it. I’ve seen these going for $300 or more online depending on how desperate people are for them. Frankly, I think the HRAP 2 SA is just as good and an upgraded HRAP3 (with Sanwa buttons) is equivalent, too. The MadCatz TE has just as big a footpad as the HRAP base but a slightly shallower/shorter base…
All the other sticks that used to be $70 or less = at least $100 online although I’ve seen SFIV branded sticks selling for $150 or more depending on production; the Hori SF IV sticks (not HRAPs, but produced in HRAP casing like the Tekken 5 sticks) are the most expensive since they were produced for Asia only; a MadCatz SE is definitely not worth over $70…
HRAP 3 SA = the rarest stick of all; I have never seen one of these for sale online; they were produced in very limited quantities last December (2008) and sold out very quickly; originally penned in for late 2007/early 2008, production was cancelled at that time because of low pre-orders or forecast for a weak PS3 market in Japan; equivalent to the Hori HRAP 2 SA but with a revised turbo switch options, Home button, and USB cable link which the HRAP 2 SA lacks – otherwise, the sticks are basically identical… Note that upgrading a regular HRAP3 with Sanwa buttons brings your stick up the level of the HRAP 3 SA…
If HRAP 3 SA’s became available again on e-Bay, they’d probably make the MadCatz TE sticks’ price-gouging look like bargains by comparison!