It doesn’t, actually.
Someone already mentioned it earlier, but rape cases have a very low rate of reaching prosecution with regard to other crimes. That’s not to say that there aren’t other ways in which women are mollycoddled by a legal system whose values and beliefs are still stuck in Leave It To Beaver land, but this story is atypical for how rape cases usually go down.
Now, let’s examine this failure at every single step.
First off, the woman is Satan. She is a failure of the gene pool, of ethics, of nature, of the human race in general. I have a hard time blaming the daughter, because when you’re that young and your mother (one of the people you’re supposed to implicitly trust above all others) is repeatedly insisting that something is true and threatening to beat you if you disagree, you’re being psychologically reconditioned at an age when you’re most defenseless against it. It’s basically the same brainwashing techniques that religious radicals and authoritarians use on their children–and for them, it usually sticks. It actually reflects favorably upon her that she eventually came to grips with the reality of the situation.
Second off, the cops absolutely failed at their jobs. Cops often fail with regard to rape investigations, but usually the failure occurs when they have substantial evidence but don’t examine it properly and the case never moves forward. This one veers hard in the opposite direction: hammering the case through on the basis of dubious evidence. How did they not instantly smell a rat? I don’t know what the fuck is wrong with these people, but they need to be fired immediately.
The prosecution failed at delivering justice, but we have to expect that, because criminal prosecution is one of the most amoral and bloodthirsty legal fields out there. They succeeded at the job of obtaining a conviction by any means available to them, which is basically the de facto job of criminal prosecutors in this country. The fact that the head prosecutor, in the face of all logic, continues to insist that he was correct is pretty telling. He’s not wrong if you ignore his obligation toward truth and justice and look at things on his terms–his sociopathic, single-minded terms. He did his job.
The judge failed for suddenly placing super-importance on whether or not she was coerced at 15, despite not giving a shit whether or not she might have been coerced at age 9.
There’s not much about the defense here, so I have to assume it was some head-up-his-ass public defender who assumed his own client was guilty and went from there. Fail.
The real absurdity here is that if you take away any one of these pieces, the guy goes free. This collusion of so many fuckups and assholes who are either incompetent or corrupt is pretty uncanny.