CANADA CHALLENGE SYSTEM - Need the starting TOP6 for each REGION

good stuff Geese.

i think it’s a great idea especially since 3rdStrike is super competitive here. well, there’s really only 1 person who wants to be recognized as #1, but i still think it’s a fun thing to do, having the rankings change every week. kinda like what game-newton has, that ranking battle of theirs.

we’ll try to have our ranking battles taped (or replay saved on PS2) then we’ll upload them.

:rock:

But it’s your site, you should base it on your own opinion!

Sounds good man. Shit I didn’t know Japan has weekly rankings. That’s pretty dope to hear. Makes me feel like I’m on the right track haha. And vids would be really nice. Especially for big challenges like for top spot. Or inter regional challenges.

sauga ranking are so mess up.

for cvs2.

it should be something like
gerjay
calvin
alex

and the 4th 5th 6th
is a grab between me, doggy, matt, or shu.\

3s is total mess up too

i dunt even think teddy or shu even play tat game.

in marvel james and chris should be in it instead of doggy and shu

Then give me your rankings and let’s see if ppl are more pleased with those k?

I play 3s more than anyone in sauga.

Guys, I have no idea who you are talking about when you say James, etc. Please just give me your list. If you’re not sure about who you wanna place 4,5,6 then just place your gut feelings. I don’t need this to be scientific, but I do need everyone to have a clear opinion. So Angel Of Rage, could you please just post your top6 in a list format with their SRK nicks. It makes it a lot easier for me.

And you can see how it’s not as clear cut as many think. You said that Teddy doesn’t play 3S but correct me if I’m wrong, isn’t DaFlipMastaXV Teddy? He says he plays the most 3S in Sauga…so you see…it’s hard to judge, so if I get enough feedback from all teh Sauga players, I can have a good idea of the top6.

MvC2
Bry
Gerjay
Me
Matt
James
CQ

CvS2 is Gerjay, Matt, Bry, who cares about the rest
3s is practically 4 way tie b/w Me, Gerjay, Bry and Matt.

Who is James and CQ?

JD’s Super Mario avatar is best ever !!!

lol I shouldn’t be on list barely play anymore

Edit: Damn doggys better then me in marvel :sad:

About this voting thing.

I don’t like it. The Sauga list for CvS2 is definitely missing out some good players. There are plenty of good players. They just aren’t in your circle of friends and you don’t meet them often. Rich, Alex, Calvin, Wayne, Wilson and me are the people I can name off the top of my head that probably deserve to be on top 6.

My top 6 for Sauga CvS2, excluding myself

  1. Gergay
  2. Alex
  3. Calvin
  4. Rich
  5. Matt/Shu/Bry/Doggy/whoever else*

I don’t like to place myself. You guys can place me on/off top6.

*You see, I rarely ever get to play these people so I can’t say. And likewise you guys only play me once a blue moon.

But I think it’s fine to exclude some people I listed. Because a few of the people I mentioned won’t care enough to commit much time to this SF challenge system. I can’t speak for Rich, Calvin or Alex, but I know Wilson and Wayne don’t care too much about rankings.

I on the otherhand do care and will participate till I reach top 3 for CvS2.

i think poke guy is atleast top 3 on the CvS2 list
he beat arcade legend!

I just read the new challenge system.

What if the players can’t agree on a time to meet? The challenger can purposely pick times that are inconvenient for the one being challenged and likewise the one being challenged can do the same. Or maybe they really are busy people and happened to be unable to meet. Either side can make up endless excuses for not being able to meet at the desired time of the other. If this happens, how do you think it’ll appear to us (the community)? It might either look like the challenger made an empty challenge, or it might look like the one being challenged is indirectly refusing the challenge. And no one will be able to tell.

If you don’t believe me that this kind of bullshit can occur, I can write up a scenario for it to show you guys

you’re a punk

Selecting the top 6 is very trivial.

Everyone will never agree on the rankings. Instead you need to start with something. Select a few top players(ie: people who win tourneys and still compete, which excludes people like Jonstar, whom I recognize as a very good player, but the fact is he hasn’t been competing for quite a while, and alot of things may have changed. Perhaps he’s not as good now since he hasn’t been practising, or others have surpassed him due to excess practise) in each region to give their top 6 and make something out of those.

Then if anyone thinks they should be the 6th or higher on the list, they can challenge the 6th and move up to where he thinks he should be, as your challenge system suggests.

I’m just saying don’t wait for something everyone agrees with, because it won’t happen, start a list so the challenge system can begin, then the ones who see differently can try to change the list to their liking.

I edited the ranks and I’m pretty sure these are accurate. My first order of business is to lay down a challenge to Jason for top spot in Brampton MvC2 (that’s almost comedic) and to Steve for 3rd spot in 3S. I propose we have both of these challenge matches during our Sunday casual session.

Also, as Brampton’s top CvS2 player, I’m laying down a challenge to whoever the hell the Sauga 6th man is so I can bust through that ranking.

I might as well address a few things:

The mystery person Geese is referring to was me. Now before everyone freak, the ranks I gave him A) were based only on the six people he gave me and B) were given as an overall (that’s why Gerjay ranked above Bryan). Also, I did give Geese game specific ranks (only for Brampton & Sauga mind you) and my ranks are NOT what was posted in this thread for Sauga.

As for Tylor’s post. Calvin & Alex, while very good players don’t enter any tournament that isn’t at Skybox (Alex hasn’t even entered a Skybox tourney in at least a year) and can’t honestly be ranked. As for Calvin being 2nd, that’s ridiculous considering he came 5th or 7th (can’t recall) at the only tourney he’s entered for the last six months back in January.

Is Afro Rich even active?

Wilson has no place in any top 6 ranking for Sauga. He’s very good but not in the class of the top Sauga CvS2 players.

I’d probably say Sauga Top 6 was Gerjay - Tylor - Bryan - Matt - ??? - ???

You know what, fuck these rankings cause Gerjay is the only Sauga player to beat me in a CvS2 tournament in the last 2years. Oh wait, Wilson fluked out a win vs me when i had no medium kick in an 8man tournament.

I’ve been playing Rich almost every Friday. I usually play him 1-2 hours straight, 1 on 1. I’m not sure if he’d be interested in this system though. I could ask him if I ever get the chance.

I totally agree with what a few of you said before. Only people that will actively participate in this new system should be ranked (initially)

yeah, holy fuck, matt should be number 1 in mvc2 and cvs2…fuckers