Evil choices does NOT make a character evil.
The concept of “good” and “evil” is very blurred in BERSERK. Griffith is the antagonist. Not evil. Griffith is not “good” on the same basis that Guts is not “good” nor "evil"
They are antagonist and protagonist with conflicting dreams.
You’re mistaking Griffith’s dream with ambition; there is a difference. Ambition is a simple want, while a true dream is on a much grander scale. For Griffith, the pursuit of his dream overrided EVERYTHING, and the SAME thing could be said about Guts.
Guts pursued his dream when he left Griffith. Although there was not direct consequences IMMEDIATELY, Guts ruined Griffith’s plan, and in doing so, Guts started the ball rolling of how things became how they are now.
Guts leaving made Griffith rush into pursuing Charlotte, thus getting captured and tortured.
In addition, the original Band of the Hawk all chose to follow Griffith. Griffith KNEW from the VERY BEGINNING that he was above all other mortals; he did not consider anyone his equal, no one. The only person that spurred Griffith was Guts; Guts was the only person Griffith considered a friend. And with Guts leaving Band of the Hawk, Griffith lost one of his main things in his life, that was the first time another human being was important to him.
By what you said, Guts is guilty of exactly the same sins as Griffith. Guts is pursuing his dream (both before Band of the Hawk, and after) and he is killing people because they stand in his way.
If you talk about innocent characters, check Books 1-3 of BERSERK. In those 3 books alone, Guts ruined many innocent lives:
- The young girl and her father in the caravan allowed Guts to stay with them. Because Gut’s brand attracts demons, skeleton demons killed the father and the daughter. Both were innocent.
- The ugly tortured guy with 1 eye. Guts watched him get executed, and didn’t do anything about it.
- Guts completely ruined the daughter of the Slug-King apostle. He tortured the Slug-King apostle in front of her, and threw her into an emotional hell.
There are more instances of this, but I don’t know off the top of my head.
Gut’s quote:
“If you’re always worried about crushing the ants beneath you…you won’t be able to walk.”
People fail to realize that Guts and Griffith are more alike than they want to believe.
Guts is almost as selfish as Griffith, and Guts is also pursuing his dreams. Please see my reply above.