6 buttons feels better for me, the last two buttons are never used for me and are almost always covered up either by button plugs or by plexi or panel replacement to compensate that. When I had my first stick it had 8 buttons and I stuck with it for a while, I covered the last two for a really scrubby and salty reason and haven’t looked back since. I have never used the last two buttons outside of training mode in the past anyways so there was almost no reason to keep it, but most of my games are on PC so I can always bind the record/play on the keyboard instead for the most part.
I’ve never thought of playing any Mega Man game with a stick. I may have to try that.
I prefer the 8 button layout just because it’s nice to have the buttons there if you need them. Like in MK. Haven’t picked up SFV so I’m still playing USFIV and I bind PPP and KKK to 4P and 4K. When I started building custom sticks I used 6 buttons because I padhacked and the inverter hacks were confusing to me.
Are we at peak sticky? Can we have a “Unpopular opinions, come at me” sticky? Seems to have worked for new stick threads.
edit:
FWIW, I’m an 8 buttoner. 4 on top for NeoGeo is the only way to go when playing Garou or KOF. Having a button plug where button 8 should be feels weird too. It’s also weird when you can’t navigate menus because the UI expects you to have all 8 buttons wired up.
edit again:
I just refurbished my old Hori RAP 1 with a fresh Hayabusa and Kuros. 3x P/3x K as first to buttons is bloody weird, but there’s precedent, and it’s how some people did learn. Soooo go figure.